The UK Treasury is opposing a plan to cut national insurance costs for hiring young people. The proposal by Alan Milburn aimed to help nearly 1 million young Britons find work. However, officials said the plan is too expensive. Allen Simpson warned, "No national insurance contributions cut means no Milburn review."
Finance ministry angers business by rejecting Milburn report's proposal to cut employers' national insurance contributions
The Treasury is opposing a flagship plan to tackle youth unemployment under which employers' national insurance costs would be cut when hiring young Britons, sparking anger from business.
Insiders at the Treasury confirmed its "resistance" to the proposal by Alan Milburn, the former Labour minister asked by the government to produce a blueprint to help almost 1mn young people not in education, employment or training -- known as Neets -- secure work.
Milburn's review, published on Tuesday, accepted that a central part of fixing the UK's Neets crisis was making it "easier, cheaper and less risky" for companies to provide jobs to young Britons.
The centrepiece of Milburn's new "bargain between government and employers" would involve cutting employers' national insurance costs for workers aged 21 to 24, by doubling the annual earnings threshold at which contributions are made from £5,000 to £10,000.
Milburn said the cut should start in the retail and hospitality sectors, which combined provide more than one-third of jobs for young people, and be phased in over five years, stressing it should happen as "fiscal conditions allow".
However, the Treasury has said in private briefings that it will not be implementing Milburn's "hugely expensive" and untargeted national insurance proposal on the grounds it would not be cost effective.
Rachel Reeves aimed to raise about £25bn a year while chancellor through an increase in employers' national insurance contributions in her 2024 Budget. This was mainly done by slashing the earnings threshold at which employers start paying contributions, from £9,100 to £5,000.
The Resolution Foundation think-tank has previously estimated that raising the threshold for 21- to 24-year-olds back to £9,100 would cost £1bn a year, but only create 7,000 new jobs.
One Treasury insider said of Milburn's proposal: "There is a lot of scepticism in this building. It would be hugely expensive and it wouldn't be targeted."
Business, which cautiously welcomed Milburn's report because of its acknowledgment of the higher tax burden placed on employers by Reeves, expressed dismay at the Treasury's opposition to his flagship proposal.
Allen Simpson, chief executive of UKHospitality, told the FT: "No national insurance contributions cut means no Milburn review -- it becomes meaningless. Where does the government think these jobs are going to come from?"
Kate Shoesmith, director of policy at the British Chambers of Commerce, said: "If you don't address employment costs . . . the UK cannot hope to solve the Neets crisis."
Nick Stowe, chief executive of retailer Monsoon Accessorize, said he gave Milburn "huge credit" for listening to business's concerns, including on national insurance costs.
"The Treasury is another matter," he added. "If they don't roll back the clearly damaging national insurance contributions increases -- the one element that focused on the ongoing cost of employment -- it just isn't going to work."
Another chief executive said that it was "ludicrous" that the Treasury did not appreciate the impact national insurance costs had on the youth employment market.
Milburn has been adamant the Neets problem cannot be solved without business being more willing to hire, saying his broader plans for welfare and education "will count for nothing if there are no jobs for young people to go to".
He described the view that youth joblessness could be dealt with purely by making young people more prepared for work as the "biggest fallacy in public policy" in the past 50 years.
The Treasury declined to comment but highlighted remarks by Andy Burnham, who has not rejected the idea of lowering employers' national insurance costs outright.
The prime minister told LBC on Tuesday that government decisions on tax would have to wait until next year's Budget. "We're going to look at the whole of the report in the round," he said, referring to Milburn's review. "We're not ruling anything out at this point in time."
Milburn has accepted his proposal to cut employers' national insurance costs is untargeted, but told colleagues he endorsed it in an effort to shift business sentiment and also to blunt Conservative attacks about higher business taxes under Labour.
"Alan hopes they bloody well do this," said one friend of Milburn, adding that the ex-cabinet minister expected Treasury opposition. "The real question is: does the prime minister like it?"
