A judge ruled that Bill Essayli acted unlawfully as the U.S. attorney in Los Angeles. The Justice Department said it would challenge this ruling in court. The administration wants to keep interim prosecutors in place without Senate confirmation. The Supreme Court might decide the fate of these officials this winter.

A judge has ruled that Bill Essayli was acting "unlawfully" as U.S. attorney in Los Angeles. He is one of three prosecutors appointed by the Trump administration through a unique process.

The Justice Department said in a filing late Tuesday that it would challenge the latest court ruling to threaten the standing of President Trump's favored U.S. attorneys.

The new filing, in the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit, signaled a continuation of efforts by the Trump administration to leave interim prosecutors in place instead of appointing permanent U.S. attorneys who require Senate confirmation.

The latest U.S. attorney under scrutiny is Mr. Essayli, who was sworn in April 2025 as the top federal prosecutor in Los Angeles. On Monday, Judge J. Michael Seabright of the Federal District Court in Hawaii refused to stay an earlier ruling that disqualified Mr. Essayli from overseeing two pending criminal cases because he was serving unlawfully.

In response, the Justice Department said in its filing that it planned to "seek emergency relief."

Permanent U.S. attorney appointments typically require approval either by the U.S. Senate or by federal judges in the affected district. But Mr. Essayli was among a group of Trump allies who were initially appointed "interim" U.S. attorneys last year. Interim appointments expire after 120 days. After the appointments expired, the administration designated them first assistant U.S. attorneys and kept them in place running their offices on an acting basis.

The practice quickly faced legal tests, leading a variety of federal judges to reject the strategy.

Ultimately, the United States Supreme Court could decide the matter, perhaps as soon as this winter. The high court is already weighing whether to intervene in parallel cases involving the tenuous status of two other top prosecutors: Sigal Chattah in Nevada and John A. Sarcone III in the Northern District of New York. Any decision by the court in those cases, if it does intervene, would affect a range of prosecutors, including Mr. Essayli.