Republicans are debating why they lost the midterms and if President Trump is to blame. The party faces a deep divide after Democrats won 56 percent of the popular vote. Strategist David Kochel said, "It felt to me like a bit of a recall election." Many now seek a new path.
A divide is emerging in the party over what caused its wipeout midterm defeats, foreshadowing a battle over how to move forward before 2028.
After a generational flogging in the midterms, Republicans are bracing for a sharp loss of power with little consensus on how to regain their footing.
Democrats swept them out of office on the back of a public fury that rivaled the post-Watergate backlash of the 1970s, winning 56 percent of the popular vote -- a margin unparalleled in the modern era -- and ending decades-long streaks of Republican dominance in Texas, Kansas, Mississippi and South Carolina.
Republicans are now in the early stages of the soul searching that is typical for a party after major election defeats. But for this Republican Party, that period of reflection is complicated by President Trump's enduring dominance. A clear divide has already emerged between those who say he bears significant culpability for the midterm losses, and those who are unwilling to cast blame his way.
In interviews, nearly 20 Republican lawmakers, strategists and officials gave a wide range of explanations for what they called a "shellacking," an "apocalypse" and a "wholesale repudiation" of the party. They cited inflation, off-base messaging, vulnerability to Democratic attacks about corruption, and overzealous immigration enforcement.
David Kochel, an Iowa Republican strategist, called the midterms "a rejection of the president," adding that "it felt to me like a bit of a recall election -- like, 'We screwed up in 2024 and we're going to try to fix it as best we can.'"
Other party strategists, commentators and departing lawmakers have also grown far more blunt about what they see as Mr. Trump's political failings. Prominent right-leaning figures like Elon Musk, Stephen K. Bannon and Joe Rogan have distanced themselves from the president.
