Rejoining the EU would boost the UK economy twice as much as a Swiss-style trade deal, a new study found. Prime Minister Andy Burnham said leaving the EU has "not worked" for the country. Rejoining could lift GDP by 3.7 per cent, largely because business investment would finally get a rebound.
Much of the benefit would come from a rebound in business investment, which was damaged by Brexit-related uncertainty
Rejoining the EU would boost the British economy twice as much as a halfway house agreement, such as a Swiss-style trade deal, according to a new study.
Research by the Productivity Institute think-tank found that much of the economic benefit would derive from a rebound in business investment triggered by rejoining the bloc.
Prime Minister Andy Burnham is due to discuss options for a closer relationship with the EU after a summit in Brussels on Friday that will seal an initial reset in post-Brexit links.
He has said that leaving the EU has "not worked" for the country and wants to explore options to rejoin.
Among the likely possibilities are rejoining the EU and halfway houses such as joining the bloc's single market or customs union.
The Productivity Institute's study, led by Manchester University econometrician Jun Du, concluded rejoining the EU could boost UK GDP by as much as 3.7 per cent in the long term.
The lift to the UK economy equates to £112bn a year at 2025 prices -- roughly equivalent to the current budget of the Department for Education.
The paper, co-produced with the Centre for Business Prosperity at Aston University, estimated that rejoining the single market -- with similar arrangements to Norway or Switzerland -- would deliver about half the GDP gains of fully rejoining, with a boost of 1.79 per cent, or £54bn in today's terms.
A customs union with the EU could deliver a 1.26 per cent increase, worth £38bn. But in all scenarios, the gains shrank if predicted increases in investment failed to materialise.
If a deal to move closer to the EU were agreed by 2035, roughly 80 per cent of the potential uplift would be delivered within 15 years but the full benefits would not be realised until 2060, according to the research.
The increase to GDP would come from a combination of lowering trade barriers, such as customs forms and regulations, and an increase in investment, which has been hit by Brexit, the analysis found.
The paper modelled the potential impacts of multiple different scenarios, including joining a customs union with the EU or re-entering the EU single market, on the basis that the UK applied for a new relationship in 2030 following a 2029 general election.
It found that restoring investment levels -- which economists say were damaged by Brexit-related uncertainty -- would be a major component of the GDP boost.
"Our results suggest that the experience of the last 10 years matters a good deal: much of the shortfall in business investment since the referendum seems to reflect uncertainty, and arrangements that are harder to unpick would see more of it restored," Du said.
The estimates draw on a 2025 analysis, co-authored by Stanford University professor Nicholas Bloom and published by the National Bureau of Economic Research, which found that Brexit cost businesses investment upwards of 12 per cent.
Du found that further gains would stem from a reduction in trade frictions for goods and services, and a related boost to firms' productivity.
While rejoining the EU would provide strong certainty for businesses, other less complete arrangements such as re-entering a customs union or trying to expand the current Trade and Cooperation Agreement would deliver fewer improvements to investment.
The modelling also took into account the potential impacts of the shifting geopolitical landscape since 2016, including tariffs imposed by US President Donald Trump and the EU's 'Made in Europe' agenda, designed to protect against the growing threat from Chinese exports.
William Bain, head of trade policy at the British Chambers of Commerce, said the research highlighted key trade-offs on tariffs and alignment with EU regulations. "This work shows how important investment and productivity improvements are to the overall growth effects of the options," he added.
Burnham is expected to sign three deals to improve the current trading arrangements, removing border checks on food and drink exports, relinking the UK's carbon pricing scheme and a "youth experience" agreement for 18-30 year olds.
The UK government has estimated these deals will only deliver up to 0.4 per cent GDP uplift.
The Office for Budget Responsibility estimates that Brexit has caused a 4 per cent long-run hit to UK GDP, although other studies put this higher at 6 to 8 per cent.
