A US appeals court panel on Wednesday heard a challenge against Minnesota laws that allow abortions at any stage. Anti-abortion groups claim these policies violate constitutional rights. Lawyer Derek Cassidy said, "There's no question this is a termination of the most sacred constitutional right the mother has." The case continues.
Nov 18 (Reuters) - A US appeals court panel on Wednesday considered reviving a novel lawsuit claiming that Minnesota laws permitting abortions during any stage of pregnancy amount to state-sanctioned murder and violate the constitutional rights of pregnant women.
A three-judge panel of the 8th US Circuit Court of Appeals heard oral arguments in St Paul, Minnesota, in an appeal by two anti-abortion pregnancy centers, their medical directors and the National Institute of Family and Life Advocates of a judge's ruling, opens new tab that dismissed their 2024 case.
Abortion is legal in Minnesota throughout pregnancy, and the state does not require waiting periods, counseling, ultrasound viewings or other measures mandated in some other states before women can have the procedure.
The plaintiffs claim Minnesota's policies violate the US Constitution's 14th Amendment's due process protections by allowing healthcare providers to terminate pregnancies, and a pregnant woman's relationship with her unborn child, without proper safeguards such as court hearings.
Derek Cassidy, who represents the plaintiffs, told the 8th Circuit panel that Minnesota's permissive abortion framework allows women to be pressured into having abortions without any due process.
"There's no question this is a termination of the most sacred constitutional right the mother has other than her own right to live," Cassidy said.
The plaintiffs sued the state, abortion providers including two Planned Parenthood chapters, and various state medical officials.
Margaret Jacot of the Minnesota Attorney General's Office told the 8th Circuit that the case was rightly tossed out because it amounted to a policy disagreement.
"Rather than pursue the political process and call their legislators or lobby for a constitutional amendment, they came to federal court," Jacot said. "But that's not what our court system is for."
The panel includes Circuit Judges Steven Colloton and Bobby Shepherd, appointees of Republican former President George W. Bush, and Jane Kelly, who was appointed by Democratic former President Barack Obama.
The judges said little during the arguments. Colloton asked Cassidy whether the US Supreme Court's 2022 decision in Dobbs v. Jackson Women's Health Organization foreclosed his arguments. Dobbs overturned Roe v. Wade, the 1973 ruling legalizing abortion nationwide, finding that abortion was a political issue for states to regulate.
"Dobbs seems to leave these issues of determination of viability to the states," the judge said. "How do we get to the result that you're urging here?"
Cassidy said the fact that states had the power to regulate abortion did not mean they could allow it without restrictions or safeguards.
US District Judge Nancy Ellen Brasel in Minneapolis, an appointee of Republican President Donald Trump, dismissed the case last year. She said the lawsuit was riddled with defects, including failures to identify which state laws were being challenged or to establish standing for any of the plaintiffs.
Most abortion-related litigation since Dobbs was decided has focused on total abortion bans and other restrictions adopted in many states, or has involved attempts to limit access to the abortion drug mifepristone, rather than challenges to more permissive laws adopted in Democratic-led states.
The case is Women's Life Care Center v. Ellison, 8th US Circuit Court of Appeals, No. 25-2905.
