A Conservative MP says returning to the Brexit debate will hurt growth. He argues that constitutional issues consume too much time, pushing aside vital needs like defence and social care. He believes the focus should stay on domestic reform rather than reversing the 2020 exit, which could distract government ministers.

Constitutional issues become all-consuming, relegating important priorities like defence, social care or local government reform

The writer is a Conservative MP and former chancellor of the exchequer. His latest book is 'Can We Be Rich Again?'

European leaders, like voters in Makerfield, have been scratching their heads about Andy Burnham's pivot to Europe: is it a serious effort to reverse Brexit or just clever political posturing to win back Green and Liberal Democrat voters? I suspect the latter -- but we should be prepared to take the prime minister at his word. After all, a Labour source recently briefed that Burnham believes Europe is the "biggest lever you have to pull" when it comes to economic growth.

If so, that is both depressing and wrong. Depressing because whatever the merits of the argument, regaining membership of the EU or single market would take at least as long as the painful years it took to leave.

Working in both the David Cameron and Theresa May administrations showed me how utterly consuming constitutional issues become. Important priorities like defence, social care or local government reform are consigned to the long grass. Referendums or votes lost in parliament can collapse governments. And details that need careful thought are glossed over or sloganised: where will we find £18bn for a National Care Service or £11bn to hit the target of 3 per cent of GDP for defence spending when new net EU contributions could easily cost the same as either? On top of which, government ministers like John Healey, Ed Miliband, Yvette Cooper and Angela Rayner will be distracted thinking about how to hold on to their Leave-voting seats.

Maybe the pain would be worth it? I voted to remain in the EU, but I profoundly disagree. A fair analysis of the economic impact of Brexit would recognise the additional costs of border checks and the fact that some smaller businesses have stopped exporting. But since leaving the EU in 2020, our growth rates have been almost identical to France and three times higher than Germany. UK growth is slightly lower than the Eurozone's as a whole (although this year so far it has been almost double the wider Eurozone's). GDP per head is less flattering, but that is largely because of the post-2019 surge in migration, a political choice that was not forced on us by Brexit.

But how much might we have grown if we had remained inside the club? Research by the US National Bureau of Economic Research is often quoted saying that UK GDP would have been 6-8 per cent larger without Brexit. It is a thorough piece of work. But it feels implausible that, having grown at around the Eurozone average for a decade, we would have started outstripping it by nearly half again. On those assumptions, our growth would have been approaching US levels -- but without a Silicon Valley, whose AI investments have been powering the domestic economy.

The OBR predicts a 4 per cent hit to productivity over 15 years, caused by lower trade. It's too early to prove or disprove this, but we can see what has actually happened. Exports have increased overall, with declining goods volumes outweighed by soaring services exports. Goods exports have fallen by more to the EU than the rest of the world, but services exports to Europe have increased by more than to elsewhere. It feels more like a continuation of the UK's long march towards being a services superpower than a sustained Brexit impact. As manufacturing-led economies try to figure out how to compete with China, that may not be entirely unhelpful.

The opportunity cost of rejoining would also be considerable, just as it was for leaving. There are things the government could do now that would bring our annual growth back up to the 2.5 per cent pre-financial crisis average. Sorting out our planning laws, for example, could add 0.2 per cent to annual GDP growth, as would reducing energy prices. Making public services more efficient could add 0.15 per cent annually. The biggest -- but most uncertain -- impact is from AI, but even cautious economists estimate it could add 1 percentage point annually to the UK's growth.

The most fiscally beneficial step would be welfare reform. Getting the cost down to 2019 levels could save £58bn a year within five years -- if we boosted participation in the labour market to Scandinavian levels, GDP per head would be 4 per cent higher than it would otherwise be.

All such measures have the advantage of being within the direct control of ministers. But none are easy -- they require focus and political will. That is exactly what would go missing if we were sucked back into a disruptive and divisive constitutional see-saw about our relationship with the EU. Instead of destabilising the economy by debating what it can't control, the government should get on with the reforms it can.