Finland President Alexander Stubb urged European leaders to talk directly with Vladimir Putin. Stubb said, "We have outsourced European engagement with Russia for too long and I think that is irresponsible." He wants leaders to use common speaking points. Stubb and other leaders will meet in Berlin on Tuesday.

President Alexander Stubb says Europe outsourcing negotiations to US was 'irresponsible'

European leaders must speak directly with Vladimir Putin after an "irresponsible" outsourcing of Russia talks to a US administration that may be leaning towards carving up the continent into spheres of influence, Finland's president has warned.

Alexander Stubb, who spoke to Putin by phone last month, told the FT that US negotiators deserved "credit" for reviving stalled talks between Moscow and Kyiv and backing European involvement in future negotiations.

"We have outsourced European engagement with Russia for too long and I think that is irresponsible," Stubb said in an interview. "Now that we have a framework . . . I think European leaders should engage directly with Putin with the same message . . . [and] common speaking points."

The Finnish leader said Europe was at a crossroads between a repeat of the 1945 Yalta agreement, which consigned central and eastern Europe to the Soviet orbit, or of the 1975 Helsinki Accords that eased east-west tensions and promoted national sovereignty, territorial integrity and human rights.

Asked if the US was in the Yalta camp, Stubb said he "would hope that they are not".

"We don't know where the US is going to lean now. It's probably leaning more into the Yalta camp, but in the future it might lean more into the Helsinki camp," he said. "But that doesn't stop us from engaging, and I think we need to continue to do that.

"We have to understand that Russia has not won this war. And to be frank, it's not going to win this war either."

Stubb said Putin was "ready to engage with Europe", even as the continent was "late" in organising itself for such talks.

EU leaders agreed last week that the continent would be represented in Russia-Ukraine talks by officials from France, Germany, Italy, Poland and the UK, plus the EU institutions and Nato. Stubb and other leaders will meet in Berlin on Tuesday for follow-up talks on what the content of any joint European position should be.

Stubb and Norwegian Prime Minister Jonas Gahr Støre held a telephone call with Putin last month, which was criticised by some counterparts who had not been consulted in advance. Stubb defended the outreach and said it was a crucial element in a series of events that led to Europe deciding on its negotiation team.

"Now it's very important that we become the agenda setters. So number one, we need a timetable. Number two, an agenda," Stubb said. He proposed six areas of negotiation: Ukraine's security guarantees, territory and post-conflict prosperity; confidence-building measures and a ceasefire, followed by a conversation on "What kind of security do we have in the future?"

But he stressed that the proposed talks between the E5, EU and Nato national security advisers and Russian, Ukrainian and US officials would only work on technical-level aspects.

"The deal will be clinched by political leaders . . . We have to be realistic that there will be no deal without Putin's agreement. Putin is the one who decides in Russia," Stubb said.

Stubb declined to comment on a US proposal made to Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelenskyy for him to cede the eastern Donbas region to Russia in exchange for Nato membership.

"I will say absolutely nothing on Ukrainian territory because that decision is taken only by President Zelenskyy and the Ukrainian people," he said, adding that he would "work towards" Kyiv joining the alliance. Finland joined Nato in 2023 after decades of neutrality, a fast-track accession prompted by Russia's full-scale invasion of Ukraine a year earlier.

"Will Ukraine be in Nato? My answer is, I don't know," he said. "I hope they will be."