The Fifth Circuit Court of Appeals ruled Friday that the Pregnant Workers Fairness Act is unconstitutional. Judges said the law used proxy voting during the Covid pandemic, violating the Constitution’s quorum clause. "We conclude that the Act's passage was unconstitutional," the court said. The case will likely reach the Supreme Court.

The Fifth Circuit Court of Appeals said the law was unconstitutional because it was passed with proxy voting during the Covid pandemic. It is expected to be appealed to the Supreme Court.

A federal court ruled Friday night that a landmark pandemic-era law that requires employers to provide on-the-job accommodations to pregnant women passed with proxy voters in violation of the Constitution.

Legal experts said the decision would effectively invalidate the law in Texas, Louisiana and Mississippi, home to about 20 million women, and would likely have ripple effects nationally. , The law protects accommodations for pregnant workers such as bathroom and water breaks, relief from heavy lifting and time off for prenatal appointments. The decisionis expected to be appealed to the Supreme Court.

The Fifth Circuit Court of Appeals ruled 9 to 8 that the Pregnant Workers Fairness Act was passed by Congress in violation of the Constitution's quorum clause, which requires a majority of members in each chamber of Congress to be present to conduct official business.

The law was passed as part of a broader $1.7 trillion spending bill during the peak of the Covid-19 pandemic, as lawmakers authorized remote and proxy votes as a safety precaution.

"We conclude that the Act's passage was unconstitutional because the Quorum Clause does not allow proxies to be included when establishing a quorum," the judges wrote, saying that the proxy system established during the pandemic was at odds with the standards established by the framers of the Constitution. "At the Constitutional Convention, the Framers vigorously debated a quorum threshold for Congress to conduct business," the judges wrote. "Indeed, early legislatures never attempted to ameliorate such concerns via proxies, even though the Founding generation was surely aware of the existence of that device."

The court's decision was a victory for outgoing Texas attorney general Ken Paxton, who had brought the suit on behalf of the state as an employer.