New York City Buildings Department officials approved a risky plan for a Brooklyn construction site in March. Months later, the neighboring building collapsed, killing eight people. Experts said the plan should have faced rejection. A spokesman said the city has "robust safeguards" for excavation and still conducts many site inspections.
Experts say that the New York City Buildings Department approved a risky method of shoring up a structure next to a Brooklyn construction site. Months later, it collapsed.
The diagram was small, barely filling one corner in a set of engineering drawings for new construction near Flatbush Avenue in Brooklyn.
Still, engineering experts said, it laid out a plan to protect a neighboring apartment building that should have prompted skepticism -- or outright rejection -- from the New York City Department of Buildings officials who reviewed it in March.
Instead, they stamped their approval, and excavation began at 2625 Bedford Avenue, where, months later, the neighboring building would collapse amid the work, killing eight people and displacing dozens more.
The apparent lapse in oversight raises concerns about not just the city's handling of the ill-fated project in Brooklyn but its ability to oversee similar work across the city, a New York Times examination has found.
It also raises questions about the officials' decision nearly a decade ago to effectively disband a special unit in the Buildings Department that was dedicated to reviewing the type of work that was occurring in Flatbush when the building fell.
Andrew Rudansky, a spokesman for the Buildings Department, said in a statement that the city has "robust safeguards" for excavation and that the agency still proactively conducts construction site inspections.
