The Dublin government started a national conversation about the road map to a united Ireland. While nationalists applauded, unionists heckled the move. The ruling coalition parties now want an objective look at the evidence. Merging systems could cost between €3bn and €25bn, showing the many rocks along the path.

Dublin's initiative shines a light on obstacles to, as well as arguments for, a united Ireland

The writer is an FT contributing editor

The Dublin government has opened up a national conversation in the Republic about the road map to a united Ireland. Northern Ireland's nationalists have applauded and unionists have heckled. The respective hopes and fears are premature. A close look at the likely shape of unity does as much to illuminate rocks along the path as the proposed destination.

For the two parties in the Republic's ruling coalition, Fianna Fáil and Fine Gael, removing the border has been an article of faith since independence and partition in the 1920s. But the commitment has more closely resembled an aspiration than a readily achievable ambition. Éamon de Valera, one of the architects of Irish nationhood, never ceased to berate British prime ministers for dividing the island, and largely shunned the nationalists left stranded in the north.

A hard-headed look is overdue. The Good Friday peace agreement mapped a potential route to unity. Mainly nationalist Catholics in Northern Ireland now outnumber predominantly Protestant unionists. Rising prosperity in the south contrasts with economic weakness in the north. Unionists are in divided disarray, while the republican party Sinn Féin leads the province's executive.

Sinn Féin, though, is alone in demanding a timetable for the border referendums in north and south envisaged by the peace accord. In any event, Northern Ireland's shifting confessional balance has yet to be reflected in a majority for unity. Some northern Catholics are content with British rule. The emotional commitment to unity of voters in the Republic has been untested by a serious examination of the implications, most obviously the hefty economic costs.

The Futures Study Initiative announced by the Fianna Fáil leader and Taoiseach Micheál Martin accepts as much in its promise of an objective examination of the evidence. In a nod to unionists, the scenario planning also acknowledges that the existing constitutional settlement is an option alongside a united Irish state or new federal entity.

Fine Gael's Blueprint for a Unified Island is more explicit in setting unification as the end point, but admits the uncertainties surrounding the economics. Its modelling suggests that the first-year costs of filling the gap left by UK subsidies and of merging pension, health and other systems could range from €3bn to €25bn. The eventual sum would depend on the contribution from a departing Britain. Most independent analyses lean towards the higher figure.

Important as the numbers are, the politics are just as daunting. Reunification would depend on a fundamental change of mindset in the Republic, as well as a majority vote in Northern Ireland. The about two-thirds of voters in the south who now tell pollsters they want unity also assume it would be painless. The present constitution, the parliament, the flag and the national anthem would be untouched. Life would continue as before after the six counties of the north were bolted on.

In the real world, unification would foreshadow a different Ireland. It would demand a political settlement comfortable with some 800,000 people who identify as British, among them a sizeable minority who would deeply resent the transfer of sovereignty to Dublin. That means devolved political structures to assure minority rights and accord equal respect to "Britishness" and "Irishness". Sinn Féin's assumption that a simple "yes" vote would be enough would invite a repeat in a united Ireland of the sectarian division and violence that long disfigured the north.

In refusing at present to make power-sharing at Stormont work, unionism's fragmented leadership has been stubbornly undermining its own best case for remaining in the UK: that oversight from London offers the surest guarantee of prosperity and good governance for Protestants and Catholics alike. But Sinn Féin's assumption that Ireland should jump before it thinks is equally irresponsible. A referendum vote is one thing. Those steering the Dublin government's initiative will find that drawing the parameters of a successful united Ireland is a daunting project.

During the 1950s, the distinguished Irish essayist Hubert Butler argued against a rush to unity. Nationalists, he said, should concentrate on fostering harmony between north and south. Over time, the border would slip into the shadows, either falling off painlessly like a sticking plaster over a healed wound or persisting only as a line on the map "which distinguishes but not does divide". His words seem as wise now as then.