Anthropic’s stock closed up 17.1% on its Nasdaq debut, but the broader market fell 2.25%. While the AI firm saw a strong start at $97.17, the wider tech sector struggled under selling pressure. Gene Munster called the hope for a sector-wide rally “classic groupthink” amid these stretched market valuations.

Anthropic’s stock market debut delivered a strong listing-day gain but failed to revive sentiment towards technology and artificial intelligence (AI) stocks, as broader markets came under selling pressure amid concerns over stretched valuations.

The maker of Claude AI began trading on Nasdaq under the ticker ANT at $111.50, a premium of 34.3% over its IPO price of $83. The stock touched a high of $115.10 before retreating to an intraday low of $92.72. It eventually closed at $97.17, up 17.1% over the offer price but nearly 13% below its opening trade. Around 857 million shares changed hands.

In contrast, the Nasdaq Composite fell 2.25%, the S&P 500 declined 2.02% and the Dow Jones Industrial Average shed 2.19%. Nvidia, a major supplier of chips used in AI training, fell 3.3%, extending its losing streak to six sessions.

At the opening bell ceremony, Anthropic CEO Dario Amodei described machine intelligence as one of the defining moments in human history, saying the company wanted to help shape its development. President Daniela Amodei said more than half of Fortune 500 companies used Claude for applications spanning drug discovery, insurance underwriting and financial fraud prevention.

IPO fails to lift sector

The stock’s strong debut had raised expectations of a broader rally in AI shares. However, Gene Munster of Deepwater Asset Management termed this expectation “classic groupthink” in a post on X. He argued that the sell-off did not indicate waning faith in AI but reflected investors’ crowded positioning. Capital raised through the IPO, he added, could eventually flow into AI infrastructure and applications.

Economist Mohamed El-Erian offered another explanation, suggesting investors may have sold existing holdings to free up funds for Anthropic’s sizeable offering, thereby exerting pressure on other stocks without necessarily signalling declining confidence in AI.

Valuation concerns

Morningstar estimated Anthropic’s fair value at $92 a share in an analysis published on November 18, below Thursday’s closing price. Its valuation ranged from $25 in a pessimistic scenario to $188 in an optimistic one.

Brokerages were considerably more bullish. Melius Research assigned a $155 price target, Needham $150, Wolfe Research $135 and Citizens $125, all with positive ratings.

However, Capital Economics markets economist Joe Maher warned on November 19 that record levels of corporate share issuance had historically coincided with market peaks in 1999, 2007 and 2021. He said the AI-driven market rally could be approaching its peak.

Chez Anbu, head of wealth advisory at OCBC, told Investing.com that Anthropic’s strong debut had failed to halt the technology sell-off, with investors increasingly concerned that technology stocks were becoming too expensive.