Mohammed Siraj and Ravindra Jadeja were left out of India's playing XI for the first Test against New Zealand in Wellington on Thursday. Many fans questioned the decision after India struggled in the field. Batting coach Sitanshu Kotak defended the choice, saying, "this is the best XI everyone felt."
Mohammed Siraj and Ravindra Jadeja, who have been one of the most consistent performers in Test in the last few years, were left out of India's playing XI for the first Test against New Zealand in Wellington.
Mohammed Siraj was as instrumental as captain Shubman Gill in India drawing the series in England in England. With 43 wickets in 11 matches, he is India's leading wicket-taker in the ongoing World Test Championship (WTC) cycle. With his workhorse-like ethics, he has a tendency to swing the game against the tide.
Ravindra Jadeja - besides being the seniormost cricketer in India's Test contingent - has the second-best batting average in SENA countries since 2021 after Rishabh Pant.
Still, when Gill exchanged the team sheets with Tom Latham moments before the toss at Basin Reserve on Thursday, neither Siraj nor Jadeja featured in the XI. As reserves, both made a guest appearance as substitute fielders on a day where India failed to build on Jasprit Bumrah's heroics with the new ball.
No wonder then that when batting coach Sitanshu Kotak sent to address the post-match media conference on a day when India only toiled in the field for most of the day's proceedings, seven of the 12 questions were directly about Siraj and Jadeja's exclusion with a couple more about Anshul Kamboj's readiness for Test cricket and lack of support for Bumrah.
Kotak, who is not supposed to be a part of the select group that decides the XI, could only toe the team management's line. As a result, he came up with mundane responses like 'this is the best XI everyone felt', 'I personally don't think it was a wrong decision' and 'there is nothing wrong' about Siraj.
Siraj had an ordinary outing in the two-Test series in Sri Lanka in August, but he has picked 95 wickets in 23 Tests he has played in Australia, South Africa and England combined so far in his career. Besides, he appeared to be bowling in rhythm during India A's four-day tie against New Zealand A last month.
Siraj's exclusion was hinted at on Tuesday when Gill stated that the team was looking at 'four pacers' and mentioned Akash Deep and Anshul Kamboj will add 'batting depth'.
When asked about the qualities that the four pacers who were picked for the match brought to the table, Kotak said: "One obviously is pace. I would say two seam the ball well, two swing the bowl well. And when you are playing on a wicket, which is little damp, soft to start with, with a lot of grass, so obviously one with a height, which gives bounce and this is just the first day. There will be some dents. When you pick an XI, you think about all four or five days, not just one day, so that's the best possible bowling attack we felt."
As for Washington being preferred over Jadeja, Kotak said the decision was based on "the four top-order left-handed batters in the XI" and looking at the possibility of Washington being required "in the second innings".
In pace friendly conditions with a four-pronged pace attack, if India has to bank on an off-spinner to get rid of one of them, doesn't it reflect lack of faith in its pace battery? And if the team is looking at batting depth, it's baffling to see one of the best performers with the bat in challenging conditions cooling his heels.
