India defended its SAFF Championship title in 2026, but the schedule sparked a club versus country debate. Because the tournament began on November 5, outside the FIFA window, many clubs refused to release players. Coach Khalid Jamil said, "I will need time, and players should be available when I call."

Though India extended its dominance in the SAFF Championship by successfully defending its title in 2026, the tournament's schedule, which partially fell outside the FIFA international window, rekindled the 'club vs country' debate among Indian Super League clubs.

Two separate senior Indian men's national teams were in action in November in different parts of the world: one competed in the SAFF Championship, which began four days before the FIFA window on November 5, while the other faced New Zealand in two matches.

For the SAFF Championship, India was forced to field a depleted squad as most Indian Super League teams refused to release players outside the FIFA window, something India head coach Khalid Jamil lamented.

"We need to be patient, but I will need time, and players should be available when I call and not just in the window," Jamil had told The Hindustan Times.

However, Bengaluru FC head coach Pep Munoz took the opposite stance. "No. Players must be available only on FIFA dates. Clubs pay their salaries," he tweeted.

Two Bengaluru FC players were named in India's SAFF Championship squad: Chinglensana Singh and Suresh Singh Wangjam, with the latter subsequently ruled out through injury.

When Chennaiyin FC head coach Clifford Miranda and Punjab FC head coach Pavlos Dermitzakis were asked about the issue ahead of their ISL encounter following the international break, they offered differing perspectives.

Chennaiyin FC had two players -- Irfan Yadwad and Brison Fernandes -- in the SAFF Championship squad, while Punjab FC had seven: Bijoy Varghese, Muhammad Suhail, Muhammed Uvais, Nikhil Prabhu, Ricky Shabong, Khaiminthang Lhungdim and Manglenthang Kipgen.

Bijoy and Suhail joined the India squad in New Zealand after the SAFF Championship opener.

"I think we should always be there to help the national team. If you remember, for the three friendlies that came up against Brazil, Uruguay and Panama, we sent Irfan much before the start of the FIFA window. For me, and as well as the club, the board and the owners, it is very important that in the end, it's for the betterment of Indian football," Miranda said.

Miranda, who played 45 times for India, also recalled how, during his days at Dempo SC, players would be released for lengthy national team camps that did not always fall within the FIFA window.

"As far as other clubs are concerned, I really can't tell you because at the end of the day, I can understand the concerns of other coaches. A head coach is always defined by the success of the team, and it becomes difficult if you don't have the players. To each his own. But I do understand the concerns of some of the coaches," he added.

"But as I said, if it affects the club's interest, then I can understand. In the end, it shouldn't be club versus country. Clubs are out there to help the country, and the national team should understand the concerns and interests of the club. It is give and take," he concluded.

Meanwhile, Dermitzakis agreed with Munoz. " . . . We need to treat all the clubs equally," the Greek coach said.

"Nevertheless, it was our pleasure and honour that so many players were called up for the national team. We try to work with this decision and work hard. It is a problem in general. But we try to see the positive way," he added.