A team led by Simone Fratini found that strange metals get their unique properties from quantum statistics rather than electron collisions. Researchers used the t–J model to show how resistance grows linearly with temperature. Sergio Ciuchi said, "It is rewarding to see that a single ingredient can account for observations."

In an ordinary metal, electrons behave like well-defined particles that occasionally bump into imperfections or vibrations of the crystal. Many materials with strong electron–electron interactions, including the copper-oxide (cuprate) superconductors, break these rules. In these "strange metals," electrical resistance rises in a straight line with temperature over a very wide range. Electrons seem to lose their momentum at the fastest rate quantum mechanics allows, the so-called Planckian limit. What causes this is still an open question.

In a study published in Nature Physics, a team led by Simone Fratini at Institut Néel (CNRS / Université Grenoble Alpes), with Arnaud Ralko (Institut Néel), Ivan Duchemin (CEA, Grenoble) and Sergio Ciuchi (University of L'Aquila), offers a simple answer. Planckian behavior does not come from how electrons collide. It comes from the quantum nature of how they respond to an electric field.

The team used the t–J model, a standard description of strongly interacting electrons in the copper-oxide planes. With improved numerical techniques, they computed its electrical properties exactly down to temperatures that correspond to about 40 Kelvin in real cuprates, reaching record-low temperatures (lower than the effective temperatures that can be achieved in cold atom simulators)—a range earlier calculations could not reach.

The results reproduce the main features of strange metals seen in experiments:

Planckian resistance. Resistance grows linearly with temperature at exactly the Planckian rate.

Over a wide doping range. The behavior appears across a broad range of charge concentrations whenever magnetic order is suppressed, without the need for a fine-tuned "quantum critical point."

Charges move independently. Conductivity simply scales with the number of mobile charges: each one moves on its own through a fluctuating magnetic background.

The optical absorption is also strange. This also explains why optical measurements on cuprates do not fit the textbook Drude model.

A change of paradigm

The key insight comes from how the material responds at different frequencies and over time. In these "bad metals," electrons lose coherence after every single hop. The underlying current fluctuations contain no Planckian timescale at all. That scale appears only through the fundamental quantum-statistical factor that links current fluctuations to the measured conductivity, called quantum detailed balance.

"This result is the outcome of years of work on how charges move in bad metals. It is rewarding to see that a single ingredient, the quantum nature of the electrons' response, can account for so many puzzling observations," says Ciuchi of the Department of Physical and Chemical Sciences at the University of L'Aquila.

The authors describe the result as a call for a change of paradigm. In bad metals, Planckian behavior is not a property of how charge carriers scatter, but of the quantum statistical nature of their response to electric fields.

"We are now working on the experimental verification of this scenario, and there will be news very soon," says Fratini, a CNRS researcher at Institut Néel.