Biologist Sandra A. Binning and her team found that reef fish are not as vulnerable to ocean acidification as once thought. Their study showed that damselfish exposed to acidic water behaved normally and stayed safe from predators. "We conjectured that there may not be a difference in the averages."

In 2016, biologist Sandra A. Binning and a group of young researchers traveled to Australia's Lizard Island Research Station, at the northern end of the Great Barrier Reef in the Coral Sea.

Completing a postdoctoral fellowship at the time, Binning wanted to understand why ocean acidification seems to disrupt the behavior of fish living in and around coral reefs.

Now a professor in the Department of Biological Sciences at Université de Montréal, Binning is detailing what she and her research team uncovered.

Their findings are published in the Journal of Animal Ecology.

Here's what they observed: Individuals of a damselfish species exposed to water as acidic as that projected for the end of this century behaved the same as those that were not exposed and were no more likely to be eaten by predators.

A decade-old puzzle

The ocean absorbs some of the CO₂ that humans release into the atmosphere, making it more acidic. A series of studies published starting in 2009 reported that spending a few days in acidified water was enough to make reef fish hyperactive, reckless and even drawn to the scent of their predators.

"At the time, we read those studies and were struck by them," Binning recalled. "When we study behavior, we rarely see such large differences between two groups."

However, her physiologist colleagues, who were studying the underlying mechanisms, were unable to replicate the results. The team therefore returned to the sites of the original studies, during the same season, to conduct a large-scale replication study.

That study was published in Nature in 2020. Again, they failed to find the previously reported dramatic effects.

Are some fish more sensitive?

The researchers then considered another explanation. The previous studies had compared group averages, an approach that can mask differing reactions among individuals in a species.

"We conjectured that there may not be a difference in the averages, but some individuals might be more sensitive than others," Binning said. "That would be important for conservation, because it would mean that certain profiles are at greater risk," as each animal has its own personality.

To test this idea, Binning's team tracked 74 juvenile Ambon damselfish (Pomacentrus amboinensis), a small fish commonly found in shallow reefs. Each fish was placed alone in an unfamiliar tank, inside a tube in which it could take shelter, with a strange object in the center of the tank. A camera then recorded the fish's behavior for 25 minutes. Some individuals immediately ventured out to explore their surroundings, while others remained hidden or swam nervously along the walls.

Each damselfish underwent the test four times: twice in present-day water and then twice after spending four to six days in water that had been acidified or left untreated. Maintaining stable acidity is more an art than a science, Binning noted; it was achieved here thanks mainly to the expertise of Josefin Sundin, a biologist colleague in Sweden.

The 'reckless driver' trade-off

The fish behaved consistently from one test to the next. A damselfish that was daring in the first trial was generally still daring in the fourth. Water acidity made no difference, either to the group average or to individual behavior.

One decisive test remained: trial by predator. Each damselfish was placed in an aquarium with a predatory rock cod (Cephalopholis microprion), a small grouper. The two fish were initially separated by a partition and allowed to acclimate to their surroundings. Then the barrier was removed and the researchers filmed the encounter for an hour. The space was small enough to allow for predation.

The groupers often missed their target, but higher acidity did not make it any more or less likely that the damselfish would escape. The best predictor of survival was the damselfish's personality: Those that had spent the most time inspecting the strange object were about 2.7 times more likely to be eaten.

"It's like driving," Binning said. "Reckless drivers reach their destination faster but are also more likely to have an accident. This trade-off is often discussed in the literature, but has rarely been demonstrated experimentally."

What the study doesn't show

The reef acidification data lay unexamined for years partly because the necessary statistical methods did not yet exist in 2016. Binning's team sought help from evolutionary biologist Shinichi Nakagawa, now at the University of Alberta, who'd come up with models allowing comparison of each fish's behavior before and after treatment.

Publication of the article was also delayed by the retraction in August 2026 of one of the studies it cited. That article had appeared in 2010 in Ecology Letters, but the journal had identified significant errors in the data, which the article's authors attributed to poor management rather than intentional fabrication.

Binning believes this episode underscores the importance of replication studies, a cause close to her heart—hence her team's decision to make their data and analysis code publicly available.

Binning acknowledged that no conclusions can be drawn from a few days of exposure about how a fish that spends its entire life in more acidic waters will behave. "That wasn't our objective," she said. "But conservation goals can't be based on studies that report major effects that don't actually exist."