A scientific study found 23 Srinagar wards fall in high earthquake-vulnerability categories. Dense construction and narrow roads make downtown the most at-risk area. About 65 percent of buildings face collision risk during shaking. Researchers said unplanned urban growth and gaps in master plans caused this, as many buildings sit too close.
23 Srinagar wards fall in high earthquake-vulnerability categories; 65% of buildings face collision risk
Srinagar, Nov 15: Dense construction, narrow roads and closely packed buildings make downtown Srinagar the city's most vulnerable area to earthquake damage, with 23 of its 69 municipal wards falling in the high and very high vulnerability categories, a scientific study has found.
Nearly 17 sq km, or about 7 percent of the city, falls in these categories.
Nine wards, covering 1.28 percent of the city, were classified as very highly vulnerable and 14 wards, accounting for 5.7 percent, as highly vulnerable.
Another 19 wards had moderate vulnerability, 17 low and 10 very low.
High building density, narrow streets, a shortage of open spaces and the risk of buildings colliding during earthquake shaking were identified as major factors behind the vulnerability.
Uptown areas were relatively less vulnerable because of wider roads and lower building density.
About 65 percent of Srinagar's buildings face a high risk of structural pounding with neighbouring structures on at least one side.
This occurs when closely spaced buildings strike each other during an earthquake.
Nearly 98 percent of the city's buildings are masonry structures, including 86.4 percent residential and 7.1 percent commercial buildings.
Educational, religious, health, defence and other structures account for the remaining 6.5 percent.
Aali Kadal has the highest proportion of masonry buildings at 99.8 percent.
Two-storey buildings account for 50 percent of the total and those with three or more stories 42 percent.
Only 8 percent are single-storey, while 307 buildings, or 0.12 percent, have more than three floors.
Downtown also has some of the city's highest building densities.
Against a citywide average of 10 buildings per hectare, 17 downtown wards have more than 15.
Jamia Masjid leads with 46 buildings per hectare, followed by Tarabal at 39 and Aali Kadal at 30.
Bud Dal has the lowest density at one building per hectare.
Narrow roads could further impede evacuation and rescue operations.
Six wards -- Syed Ali Akbar, Bana Mohalla, Bud Dal, Zindshah Sahib, Ganpatyar, and Safa Kadal have average road widths of less than 7 feet.
The researchers linked the city's vulnerability partly to unplanned urban growth and gaps in implementing successive master plans.
Srinagar's population rose from about 2.50 lakh in 1961 to 15 lakh in 2011, increasing pressure on its urban infrastructure.
They recommended restricting construction in densely populated, highly vulnerable areas, protecting open spaces for emergency evacuation and retrofitting vulnerable buildings.
"Since green and open spaces are used as evacuation places, it is strongly advised that new construction in these areas, as well as the development of these spaces, must be avoided," the study states.
The researchers also called for emergency action plans, fire services, shelters and specialised medical facilities in vulnerable areas, along with stricter enforcement of building codes, earthquake-resistant construction and public awareness programs.
The assessment covers the physical vulnerability of buildings and infrastructure but does not examine residents' socioeconomic vulnerability.
The researchers recommended including these factors in future assessments.
The study was conducted by Midhat Fayaz, Prof Shakil Ahmad Romshoo, Irfan Rashid, and Rakesh Chandra.
Using Cartosat-2 satellite imagery, geographic information system (GIS) mapping and field surveys, they assessed six parameters across Srinagar's 69 wards and collected 8000 ground-validation points.
Titled 'Earthquake vulnerability assessment of the built environment in the city of Srinagar, Kashmir Himalaya, using a geographic information system,' the study was published with funding from the Union Ministry of Earth Sciences.
