DNA research shows why the Bombay duck population surged in the East China Sea. In 2005, this fish made up 83% of the total catch. Scientists found genetic traits that helped it thrive in changing waters. "We consider the Bombay duck as a new kind of invader," said Bin Kang.
The Bombay duck (Harpadon nehereus) is a small marine fish that lives in the northern Indian Ocean and western Pacific, including the East China Sea. For many years, fisheries in the East China Sea caught very few Bombay ducks.
In 2005, however, 83% of the total catch in the East China Sea's main fishing grounds consisted of Bombay duck, and its numbers surged again in later years. The factors contributing to these surges have not yet been clearly elucidated.
Researchers at Ocean University of China, Sun Yat-sen University's Shenzhen campus and other institutions recently tried to shed more light on these factors by studying the DNA of Bombay ducks caught along China's coast.
Their study, published in Proceedings of the Royal Society B, identified genetic characteristics linked to low-oxygen tolerance, salt and water balance, and immune function, which may have helped the Bombay duck thrive in changing coastal habitats.
"For a long time the Bombay duck was merely a small bycatch species in the East China Sea, and for years it was not even recorded in official statistics," Bin Kang, first author of the paper, told Phys.org.
"Then, around 2005, it erupted: it came to account for 83% of the total catch from the main fishing grounds of the East China Sea, and it has broken out repeatedly in the years since—turning from a bit player into a dominant species and reshaping community structure and ecosystem functioning."
Kang explained that it is unusual for native marine fish to become dominant so suddenly. When this happens, the surging species can reshape its ecosystem and reduce the resources available to other species.
"We consider the Bombay duck as a new kind of invader—a 'native' invader," said Kang. "The question that really motivated this study was: what made such success possible?"
Examining the DNA of Bombay duck fish
Kang has been studying the Bombay duck for years, and his past research has already yielded valuable insight about the fish. For instance, he and his colleagues studied the responses of Bombay duck to low oxygen (hypoxia) and proposed that declining oxygen levels could explain its rise in abundance.
They also studied how the Bombay duck regulates its genes in response to cold temperatures. Finally, they examined the fish's anatomy and feeding strategies, its growth and population trends in the northern East China Sea and mercury contamination in fish caught by local fisheries.
"Building on my earlier work, we proposed a hypothesis: the Bombay duck may have been genomically preadapted to this hypoxic, polluted and fluctuating environment all along, so that once external pressures arose (overfishing freeing up ecological niches, intensifying hypoxia, etc.) it could expand rapidly," explained Kang.
To seek evidence supporting this hypothesis, the researchers assembled and analyzed chromosome-scale genomes for the Bombay duck and a related species, the brushtooth lizardfish (Saurida undosquamis). These are reconstructions in which most of an organism's DNA is organized into sequences that correspond to individual chromosomes.
The team also examined the DNA of 48 Bombay ducks collected at six distinct sites along China's coast. Notably, fish taken at different sites did not fall into distinct genetic groups, suggesting that they belonged to a single interbreeding population spanning the areas sampled.
"The paper had three main objectives," said Kang. "The first was to assemble and annotate chromosome-level reference genomes for the Bombay duck and for its closely related outgroup, the brushtooth lizardfish (Saurida undosquamis).
"The second was to use comparative genomics to examine gene family expansion and contraction along the Bombay duck lineage, as well as genes under relaxed selection, intensified selection and positive selection. Finally, we wanted to use population-level whole-genome resequencing to test whether geographic isolation exists along the Chinese coast and to detect recent selective sweeps."
In their analyses, the researchers examined how DNA varied among the fish they sampled. This allowed them to gather clues about which genetic changes may have been favored by natural selection. More recent signs of selection also pointed to the role of genes linked to immune function.
"Sample collection was mainly conducted by Lin-Long Wang, then a Ph.D. student of Kang," explained Rongfeng Cui, corresponding author of the paper. "The samples were obtained from fishery boats straddling a wide geographical range along the Chinese coasts. One of these individuals was used for assembling a reference sequence of Bombay duck, while others were subjected to short-read resequencing."
Comparisons with a closely related species
When exploring the factors that may have contributed to recent surges in Bombay duck in the East China Sea, the team chose the brushtooth lizardfish because it is closely related to the Bombay duck, but it had not undergone a similar population surge.
"After looking up the phylogenetic tree and fish books, we decided that the closely related genus Saurida would be a good and feasible option," explained Cui.
"We sampled and assembled from a single lizardfish to be used as the 'outgroup.' Later methods are mostly bioinformatic and are now commonly applied in the field of evolutionary genomics. Genes showing unusual statistics may suggest that they are under natural selection in Bombay duck and might point to the genetic predisposition for the fish to become natively invasive."
The researchers found that the Bombay duck had three copies of a gene called epas1, which helps to regulate responses to low oxygen levels. The lizardfish they compared it to only had one copy of this gene.
"The epas1 gene has been repeatedly shown to be adaptive for high-altitude hypoxia in different vertebrates including humans," said Cui. "The Bombay duck genome contains three copies of epas1, which might be consistent with their preadaptation to hypoxia."
A new perspective on fish invaders
The findings gathered by Kang, Cui and their colleagues suggest that some native fish species may already possess traits that give them an advantage when their environment changes. If conditions in marine ecosystems shift in their favor, their numbers could thus surge, disrupting the ecosystem they inhabit.
"The core implication of this work is that species already genomically preadapted to environments affected by global change may abruptly become new native invaders," said Kang. "Global change—expanding hypoxia, eutrophication and overfishing that releases ecological niches—may reorganize existing marine communities by elevating these preadapted species into dominance."
The team's recent work could potentially inform the work of fishery managers, particularly the monitoring of native species that might become more abundant as coastal conditions change.
"We must look not only at non-native species as potential invaders, but also guard against the 'invasionization' of a native species," explained Kang.
Notably, the Bombay duck is a "non-model" organism, which means that biologists don't have established laboratory tools for studying and manipulating its genes in laboratory settings. This prevented the team from directly testing whether the extra copies of epas1 help the Bombay duck survive in low-oxygen water.
"It would be informative if we could replicate these genomic changes (e.g., by increasing the epas1 copy) in a model fish species (say, the zebrafish or the turquoise killifish) to directly test their role in hypoxia tolerance," added Cui.
"Another interesting direction would be more for ecological security, to apply genomic and population genetics to predict the likelihood of a native species to become invasive (but I would imagine this to be very challenging and controversial)."
