West Bengal saw its fifth police encounter on November 15 since Suvendu Adhikari became chief minister. Ratan Sheikh died in the incident after allegedly firing at a cop. Adhikari said, "If someone tries to kill the police, will they throw flowers back?" He is now following Yogi Adityanath’s strict playbook.

The state's new BJP chief minister is borrowing from Yogi Adityanath's UP playbook, most notably his penchant for police encounters. But a copy paste model has its hazards

On November 15, West Bengal saw its fifth police 'encounter' since Suvendu Adhikari took over as chief minister of the state's first BJP government in May. The deceased, Ratan Sheikh, 31, was wanted in 36 cases, and had allegedly fired at and injured a cop in Santiniketan two days before. Sheikh was shot dead in retaliatory fire after he is said to have pulled out a concealed weapon while in custody. The incident, per se, would not have made the front pages but for the CM's standard response on the possible extra-judicial action. "If someone tries to kill the police, will they throw flowers back?" he asked reporters. A week before, after the fourth 'encounter', the analogy had been about roshogullas instead of flowers.

Sweetmeats and flora notwithstanding, Bengal's ninth chief minister has been charting a course quite unfamiliar to what the state has ever seen before. From being one of Trinamool Congress chief Mamata Banerjee's poster boys in the noughties, to breaking ranks and joining the BJP before the 2021 assembly election and now leading a BJP government in the state, Suvendu's transformation has come almost full circle. Almost, for the Nandigram strongman has yet to put his stamp on the government. For this, he is looking at the template set by his BJP counterpart in Uttar Pradesh, 'bulldozer' man, Yogi Adityanath.The admiration was evident long back.

In 2023, as leader of the Opposition, Suvendu had declared that Bengal needed a strict ruler like Adityanath, and that those accused of violent crimes should be taken out in 'encounters'. That perhaps explains the Bengal Police's current enthusiasm for shootouts -- they report to Suvendu as the minister for home affairs. However, if encounters are the benchmark of law and order, the Bengal CM has some catching up to do with his UP counterpart. The state has seen 17,000-odd encounters since Yogi came to power in 2017.Suvendu's open appreciation aside, the camaraderie between the two leaders was hard to miss during the Bengal poll campaign.

The CM even touched Yogi's feet at one of the events that the latter graced. At his swearing-in, the UP CM draped a saffron stole around Suvendu's neck, which matched with the saffron kurta he wore for the occasion. TRIGGER HAPPY: Encounter victims Ratan Sheikh from the Nov. 15 incident, and rape-murder accused Dilip Roy, who was shot dead on November 9 BULLDOZER RAJ IN BENGALThe Bengal administration's bulldozer drive has been one of the clearest parallels with UP. Within days of taking oath, the new government announced "zero tolerance" on illegal constructions, with the drive focused on locations such as Kasba, Tiljala, Ekbalpur and Mominpur, all Muslim neighbourhoods in Kolkata.

It took a petition by the CPI(M) in the high court for the judges to intervene and put a stay on the blanket action. The heavy vehicles are still rolling, though, but the target is mostly the 'illegal' party offices of the TMC. The giant machines have also found utility in the 'Nasha Mukt Bharat 2029' anti-drug campaign. Suvendu himself was been seen operating them at public events in Balurghat in Dakshin Dinapur and New Town in North 24 Parganas, where some 500,000 bottles of illegal cough syrup were destroyed.However, Suvendu's borrowings from the Yogi playbook go beyond encounters and bulldozers; he is also spouting the UP CM's Hindutva vocabulary.

On various occasions, he has vowed to end "love jihad" and "land jihad", and sounded dire warnings against cow slaughter and religious conversions. Reacting to the latest encounter, Suvendu said that goondas and rapists would do well to flee to Bengal. The CM has also been quite fixated with neighbouring country Bangladesh, repeatedly promising to deport infiltrators, ordering crackdowns on illegal madrasas in border areas and setting a November 30 deadline for the completion of the controversial Citizenship (Amendments) Act or CAA hearings. Most recently, his comment during the Durga Puja festivities -- that only believers in sanatan dharma would be allowed to touch Durga idols during immersion -- caused much heartburn.

That this right-wing cultural assertion came after the 19 deaths in the Chorebagan pandal stampede only darkened the mood further in the state. CAMPUSES IN CROSSHAIRSThe Suvendu government has also not taken kindly to Left-controlled college campuses, especially Jadavpur University (JU) and Presidency College. In late August, a mob consisting allegedly of members of the Akhil Bharatiya Vidyarthi Parishad (ABVP) and the Bharatiya Janata Yuva Morcha, student and youth wings of the ruling party respectively, entered the JU grounds, and beat up students. The chief minister later publicly sided with the attackers, saying sympathisers of "anti-national forces" must be taught a lesson.Suvendu reiterated the message on November 7, urging the ABVP to "clean up" the two campuses of "dimagi Naxals".

The Satyajit Ray Film and Television Institute, run by the Union I&B ministry, was another target of attack in late September, the perpetrators here being a little-known right-wing outfit, the Bangiya Hindu Jagaran Mancha.Also, like Yogi, Suvendu seems to have a low threshold for criticism of any kind. The police have arrested several media mavens, among them Surajit Shee, who has 252,000 followers on Facebook. After the Chorebagan stampede, he was arrested on such charges as endangering the country's integrity and public mischief. A reminder here: on November 3, the Allahabad High Court called UP's civil liberties situation "shameful".

The Oppositions says Bengal seems intent on going down the same path.Indeed, six months into his term, Suvendu has not exactly endeared himself to many sections of the public. The Opposition is livid over the 'encounter' culture he has brought to the state. Ex-minister and Ballygunje MLA Shobhandeb Chattopadhyay of the Mamata TMC says publicity from encounters cannot replace due process of law. The TMC chief's nephew and MP, Abhishek Banerjee, wants to know why the culprits in the Chorebagan tragedy have not been encountered. "If (you) have the guts, encounter your own nephew," he says (Debdeep Adhikari was chief patron of the Chorebagan pujo committee).THE RUMBLINGSThe CM's conduct is creating unease within the BJP as well.

While he is hugely popular with the cadre, some elements in the state leadership feel Suvendu is using Hindu nationalism as an excuse for his excesses. Others are of the opinion that he is playing to the gallery. "The Bengal government is no longer Kolkata-centric," a BJP source explains. "Only three cabinet ministers are from Kolkata. Most of the cabinet comes from the mofussil regions. And, in the villages, the excesses and far-right approach has takers."Critics also point out that, for all the tough-on-crime rhetoric, the CM's cabinet is hardly a collective of law-abiding citizenry. The Association of Democratic Reforms analysed the records of 40 ministers and found that many have criminal cases against them.

Suvendu himself has 29 criminal cases registered against him.Some of Suvendu's actions also seem to be generating sympathy for Mamata, like the allegations that Leader of the Opposition and TMC MLA Ritabrata Banerjee works at the CM's behest. The fact that the state has started acting against the TMC MLAs who had sided with Ritabrata but have since returned to Mamata, lends credence to the charges. The government's 'petty moves', such as supporting the vandalism of the Left Front's book stalls during the Durga Puja, has also not gone down well.A STRAINED ANALOGYPolitical analyst Prof. Subhamoy Maitra says Suvendu's biggest success is convincing voters about his Hindutva credentials.

"An organisation like the RSS may not be so gullible. His disparaging statements against Hindutva and the BJP from the past will never go away," says Maitra. That wouldn't worry Suvendu too much. He only has to look to neighbouring Bihar and Assam to see how well turncoats have done in the BJP.However, what Suvendu needs to keep in mind is that Bengal and UP fundamentally differ in their political culture. The former has historically been shaped by ideological movements whereas UP has always connected more with identity and caste politics, Hindi belt power dynamics and such. A copy-paste Yogi model might not be the right answer for the eastern state.

Funnily enough, encounter killings may be the one area where the two states may share common ground. Bengal has a history of staged encounters, right from the Naxalite crackdown in the 1960s and '70s and down to the Left Front and TMC years. What is new is the open political endorsement of it now.- EndsMust Watch