The first public hearing on Maharashtra’s proposed Uniform Civil Code started Saturday at Konkan Bhavan. Muslim groups questioned the need for one law, while transgender representatives sought rights for chosen families. Mohammed Khalid said, "If they are pushed into one framework, it could divide society in the future." Many others spoke.
Muslim organisations questioned the need for a common law, women's groups called for changes in personal laws, transgender representatives sought legal recognition for chosen families, while others backed the demand for one law across communities.
The first day of public hearings on Maharashtra's proposed Uniform Civil Code (UCC) on Saturday brought sharply divergent voices before the committee headed by retired Supreme Court judge Justice Ranjana Prakash Desai. While Muslim organisations questioned the need for a common civil law, arguing that it could interfere with religious freedom and the constitutional protection of cultural diversity, women's groups called for gender-just family laws, transgender representatives sought legal recognition for chosen families, and members of Nomadic and Denotified Tribes (NT-DNT) communities urged the government not to overlook their distinct marriage customs and traditions.
There were also voices strongly supporting the UCC, with some arguing that a common law would ensure equality in matters of marriage, divorce and inheritance. Others, however, said its implementation should be voluntary or should not come at the cost of customary practices.
The hearing was held at Konkan Bhavan in Navi Mumbai as part of the committee's district-wise consultations to gather suggestions and objections on provisions concerning marriage, divorce, live-in relationships, maintenance, guardianship and inheritance. Five of the seven state appointed memers of the Committe arring Justice Ranjana Prakash Desai and Ramesh Patange were present for the fist day of the hearing. The hearing for Konkan Divison will continue on Sunday as well.
Muslim groups question need for UCC
Muslim organisations, including representatives of Jamaat-e-Islami Hind and the All India Muslim Personal Law Board (AIMPLB), raised concerns over the proposed legislation, arguing that India's diversity and constitutional guarantees of religious freedom needed to be respected.
Mohammed Khalid of Jamaat-e-Islami said forcing different communities into one legal framework could deepen divisions.
"Different communities live in a diverse society. If they are pushed into one framework, it could divide society in the future. This is problematic for society in general," he said.
A representative of the AIMPLB, Mufti Jasimuddin Qasmi, argued that communities should be allowed to follow their personal laws in family matters. He said the proposed code went against the principle of unity in diversity.
Dr Azimuddin, also representing concerns raised by the AIMPLB, questioned the necessity of introducing the law, saying existing legal provisions were sufficient. He argued that the need for a UCC should be established through evidence, constitutional analysis and meaningful public consultation rather than assumed on the basis of uniformity.
Congress MLA Amin Patel who joined through tele conferencing also opposed the move, describing it as interference in religious practices. He questioned the consultation process, particularly the use of a questionnaire with yes-or-no answers when the proposed law itself had not been made public.
"If we don't know what the government is planning to bring, how can people give their views? This is interference in the religious affairs of people," he said.
Not all Muslim representatives approached the issue as a defence of existing personal laws. Sabah Khan of the Savitri Fatima Foundation for Inclusive Development said reforms were necessary, but the process should not create the perception that the UCC was intended to target Muslim men.
"Bring a law to help people rather than create the perception that it is being brought to punish Muslim men," she said.
Khan also called for the removal of provisions such as restitution of conjugal rights, arguing that discriminatory practices within personal laws needed to be addressed.
Transgender groups, women's organisations seek recognition of diverse families
Representatives of LGBTQI groups and women's organisations sought legal recognition for relationships and family structures beyond conventional marriage.
Chayanika Shah representing Hasratein-e-Zindagi-Mamooli a queer feminist collective said people who did not wish to enter marriage should not be denied legal protection. She called for civil partnerships between two adults and recognition of chosen families.
"People who want to get married should be given that right. Chosen families need to be recognised, and nominated representatives should be provided legal status," she said.
She also highlighted the difficulties faced by transgender persons who leave their natal families and depend on chosen families for care and support. Recounting one such experience, she said accessing medical care while living with a chosen family had been particularly difficult.
Sandhya Gokhale of the Nari Atyachar Virodhi Manch (Forum Against Oppression of Women), which has worked on gender justice since 1980, called for reforms across family laws, including marriage, adoption, inheritance and civil partnerships.
She cautioned against excessive state intervention in consensual relationships, including live-in arrangements.
"The state does not have the right to go into the personal lives of people. I can stay with whoever I want," she said, opposing provisions that could lead to surveillance or unnecessary regulation of such relationships.
The organisation also sought changes to adoption rules and called for a social security framework addressing the needs of marginalised groups.
NT-DNT communities seek protection for customs
Representatives of Nomadic and Denotified Tribes sought a separate assessment of how the proposed code would affect their traditional marriage systems and cultural practices.
Their representation pointed out that communities such as the Pardhi, Banjara, Gosavi, Gondhali, Garudi, Vadar and Devipujak have distinct social structures, family traditions and marriage customs.
They demanded an independent study of these practices, legal recognition of traditional marriages, protection of women's rights relating to divorce, maintenance and inheritance, and a separate public hearing for the communities.
They also sought consultations with community organisations and researchers, along with constitutional safeguards for communities covered by special protections.
Supporters call for one law
Several participants supported the UCC, arguing that a common framework could promote equality in personal and family matters.
