Supreme Court Justice BV Nagarathna said women in high public office do not mean equality is achieved. On November 18, she noted that many women still face barriers to education and rights. "It would surely be a mistake to measure the progress of Indian women's rights only," she said.

Supreme Court Justice BV Nagarathna has said that the presence of women in senior positions of power cannot be considered evidence that gender equality has been achieved across Indian society, pointing out that several women continue to face barriers to education, employment, property rights and access to justice. Delivering the inaugural Cornelia Sorabji Memorial Lecture at Somerville College, University of Oxford, on November 18, the judge said women's empowerment would remain incomplete unless every girl had the freedom to be born, receive an education, make decisions about marriage, pursue a career and live without fear of violence at home, at work or in public spaces.

The lecture, titled "The Doors She Opened: Cornelia Sorabji and the Progress of Women's Rights in India", was organised at the Oxford India Centre for Sustainable Development. Women's rights go beyond representation in public office Justice Nagarathna cautioned against judging India's progress on gender equality merely through the increasing presence of women in positions of authority or the enactment of legislation protecting their rights. "The existence of women in high public office does not establish that equality has been achieved throughout society. A woman may hold a senior position while other women remain excluded from education, employment, property, or effective legal remedies," she said.

She observed that constitutional protections might exist on paper but remain difficult to access because of the financial burden, delays and social repercussions associated with approaching courts. A legal guarantee, she said, does not necessarily translate into meaningful protection when women face obstacles in enforcing their rights. Justice Nagarathna added that judicial decisions alone cannot ensure safe working environments, access to education for every girl or timely protection for survivors of domestic violence. "It would surely be a mistake to measure the progress of Indian women's rights only by the number of discriminatory provisions that have been struck down or the beneficial statutes that have been enacted," she said, adding that India's constitutional project remained unfinished.

Every girl must have the right to be born and pursue her choices Emphasising the fundamental conditions necessary for women's independence, the judge identified several rights that must be guaranteed to women, including the right to be born, education, freedom to choose a marital partner, career opportunities, inheritance and personal safety. "The right to be born as a girl child, the right to education, marital choice, to pursue a career of one's choice, the right to inherit property and safe conditions for women both at home as well as in the workplace and most importantly, on a public street are salient aspects which would empower women to a large extent in India," she said.

She argued that when women could independently pursue their aspirations and make decisions about their lives, the very idea of empowerment would become less significant. "If the women are able to fulfil their choices and goals, I feel that the word 'empowerment' would pale into insignificance," she said. The judge also called for introspection within Indian society, particularly among men, pointing to the difficulties faced by qualified women in obtaining educational and professional opportunities. "I have had the benefit of education and a career to pursue, but there are many women in India who find it difficult to pursue education or have a career, even though well qualified," she said.

Violence, unpaid care work and economic inequality Justice Nagarathna highlighted women's security, financial independence and access to legal remedies as continuing concerns despite constitutional safeguards and legislative measures. She said the central issue was whether women could approach the legal system without apprehension of social disapproval, retaliation or financial vulnerability. "The question is whether a woman can invoke the protection of the law without the fear of stigma, retaliation or economic insecurity. This challenge cannot be overcome by simply enacting more laws," she said.

The judge also drew attention to the unequal distribution of unpaid household and caregiving responsibilities, which continues to influence women's professional and personal decisions. She said the disproportionate responsibility for domestic work and sustaining family life continued to fall on women, limiting their ability to participate equally in employment and other opportunities. Justice Nagarathna further stressed that gender equality must account for the different circumstances of women, including variations arising from caste, class, disability, religion, geographical location and financial conditions.

"There is no single experience of being a woman," she said, adding that changes in legislation often move faster than the prevailing social attitudes and cultural assumptions within society. Calls for greater representation of women lawyers Addressing gender representation in the legal profession, Justice Nagarathna reiterated her support for reserving one-third of positions on government panels for women lawyers. Her proposal covers government panels, including those representing public sector undertakings, as well as appointments in legal aid institutions. "I have consistently advocated for one-third reservation for women lawyers on government panels, including those representing public sector undertakings and in the sphere of legal aid," she said.

She emphasised that equal opportunity in the legal profession should extend beyond allowing women to enter the field. It should also provide them with opportunities for professional growth, institutional leadership, government representation and participation in legal decision-making. "The door of the legal profession must, after all, remain open not only to entry, but to professional advancement and institutional leadership," she said. Cornelia Sorabji's legacy and landmark judgments Reflecting on the contribution of Cornelia Sorabji, widely recognised as India's first woman practising lawyer, Justice Nagarathna said her life demonstrated how knowledge must translate into the ability to secure justice and exercise rights.

"The doors have been opened by Cornelia. Our responsibility is to ensure that they remain open for women," she said. The judge also traced the Supreme Court's evolving approach to women's rights through several important decisions. She referred to CB Muthamma Vs Union of India (1979), in which Justice VR Krishna Iyer held that marriage could not be used to impose restrictions exclusively on women. She also discussed Air India Vs Nergesh Meerza (1981), in which the Supreme Court invalidated the automatic termination of air hostesses upon their first pregnancy. Other significant developments included the Shah Bano judgment concerning maintenance for divorced Muslim women, the Vishaka guidelines on workplace sexual harassment, subsequently replaced by legislation in 2013, and the Anuj Garg judgment, which addressed the issue of protective paternalism.

She also highlighted judgments granting permanent commission to women officers in the Army and Navy. Among the decisions she authored or participated in, Justice Nagarathna mentioned Association of Old Settlers of Sikkim Vs Union of India (2023). The Supreme Court struck down a tax provision that denied an exemption to Sikkimese women marrying men who were not from Sikkim. She also referred to Prabha Tyagi Vs Kamlesh Devi (2022), which clarified that a woman did not need to be residing with her husband when seeking relief under the Domestic Violence Act. Referring to the Deepika Singh maternity leave judgment, she said pregnancy and childbirth should not force women to choose between motherhood and their careers.

Constitutional amendments and political representation Justice Nagarathna also highlighted the role of constitutional provisions in increasing women's participation in elected institutions. She referred to the 73rd and 74th Constitutional Amendments, which provided for reservation of at least one-third of seats for women in panchayats and municipalities. The Constitution (106th Amendment) Act, 2023, extended the principle of reservation to the Lok Sabha and state legislative assemblies. In Karnataka, her home state, reservation for women in local bodies is not less than 50 per cent. However, she maintained that institutional representation and legislative changes must translate into substantive equality in women's everyday lives.