The Supreme Court asked political parties to justify indefinite protests at Delhi’s Ramlila Maidan during a November 27 hearing. The court issued notices to Congress, BJP, AAP, and AISA after traders complained that protests block roads and hurt businesses. Judges said they must balance the right to protest with others' rights.
NEW DELHI: If you want to protest at Ramlila Maidan, come to the court and justify it. That is the message the Supreme Court sent on Wednesday to Congress, BJP, AAP and AISA and others who wanted to protest there for an indefinite time.
The Court also issued notice to all four parties on hearing the traders' plea to denotify Ramlila Maidan as a designated protest site. A bench of CJI Surya Kant and Justices Joymalya Bagchi and V Mohana said the matter will be heard on November 27 along with the petitions asserting the right to protest.
On November 3, the Court had told traders, Delhi Kirana Committee and Delhi Iron and Hardware Merchant Association, that it would not decide the issue without hearing the organisers. The traders complied, amended their plea, and added the parties.
Senior advocate Mukul Rohatgi argued that the Delhi Police notification of October 11 designating Ramlila Maidan was issued without consulting traders, without studying traffic, and without fixing duration or crowd limits.
The CJI said: "The amended writ petition taken on record. Let notices be issued to the newly-added respondents... The first category concerns the right of protesters to protest. Rohatgi's matter concerns the rights of others, their competing fundamental rights. Both will have to be taken together."
Traders say it is the soul of Delhi's economy, where livelihoods are earned.
Solicitor General Tushar Mehta said the traders' plea should be heard with the main batch, including the petitions on police excesses during protests.
The Court will also hear CPI(M) MP M A Baby's plea on right to protest. November 27 will not just decide a ground. It will decide whether protest in Delhi can continue as before, or whether a new framework, with time, place and manner restrictions, is needed.
Traders argued that Ramlila Maidan is not an isolated ground. It sits in the heart of Delhi's wholesale economy, Chandni Chowk, Chawri Bazar, Khari Baoli, Sadar Bazar, Connaught Place. Every protest blocks roads, chokes access, shuts shops.
They claim Delhi does Rs 500-600 crore business daily, of which Rs 200-250 crore is jeopardised during festive season October to January, affecting 10 lakh establishments and 1 crore livelihoods due to these protests.
