The Supreme Court ruled that high courts cannot add lump-sum amounts to motor accident compensation without clear legal calculations. In its November 20, 2026 judgment, the bench called such hikes pure guesswork. The court recalculated the award for Sabir, who suffered permanent disability after a 2013 accident, to Rs 11,75,106.

New Delhi: The Supreme Court has ruled that a high court cannot simply add a lump-sum amount to motor accident compensation without explaining the legal basis or calculation method, calling such an approach pure guesswork rather than a proper judicial assessment of just compensation.

The high court had increased the Motor Accident Claims Tribunal’s award by Rs 2 lakh under the Motor Vehicles Act but failed to indicate how it arrived at the figure or examine individual heads of compensation.

“The high court ought to have adverted to each head under which compensation was awarded by the Tribunal and then determined whether such grant was just or not. A composite increase… without indicating the basis… could be termed as an exercise of guesswork rather than applying the law,” the bench observed, referring to the principles laid down in Raj Kumar Vs Ajay Kumar (2010).

The accident occurred on April 24, 2013. Sabir, then aged 27-30 and earning by collecting and selling milk, was riding his motorcycle with his wife when a truck driven rashly hit them. He suffered 50 per cent permanent disability in his right leg.

Finding no evidence of monthly income, the Supreme Court assessed loss of earnings on the basis of minimum wages for an unskilled worker notified by the Labour Commissioner for the relevant period.

In its judgement on November 20, 2026, the court accepted the functional disability at 50 per cent given the nature of his work, and granted Rs 25,000 for attendant care required for daily activities.

After recalculating all heads, the court held Sabir entitled to Rs 11,75,106 with seven per cent interest from the date of the claim petition (June 28, 2013) till realisation.