The Delhi High Court dismissed a plea by a US citizen seeking to convert her tourist visa into a spouse visa. Justice Amit Mahajan said, "there is no inherent or legally enforceable right of a foreign national to seek entry or stay into India." Marriage does not guarantee residency rights.

The court dismissed a plea by a US citizen who had sought conversion of her tourist visa into a spouse visa after marrying an Indian man.

The Delhi High Court has dismissed a plea by a US citizen seeking conversion of her tourist visa into a spouse visa after marrying an Indian man, observing that a foreign national cannot claim an unconditional right to reside in India or insist upon a particular category of visa merely based on a matrimonial relationship.

Justice Amit Mahajan observed that the entry or stay of a foreign national in India is not a matter of enforceable right against the State but a matter of sovereign discretion.

"...the petitioner, a foreign national, essentially seeks issuance of directions to secure her stay in India and her claim is destined to fail because there is no inherent or legally enforceable right of a foreign national to seek entry or stay into India. The mere fact that the petitioner has entered into a marriage with an Indian citizen does not, by itself, confer an automatic or indefeasible right to conversion of her existing visa into an Entry (X-1) Visa," the order read.

What did the court dismiss plea?

The petitioner, a US citizen, told the court that she was married to an Indian citizen and had applied to convert her existing e-tourist visa into a spouse visa. She alleged that despite submitting the requisite documents, the authorities did not process her application favourably and have, instead, subjected her and her husband to repeated enquiries on the ground of the age difference between them.

The authorities, however, told the court that the scrutiny of her application was not based merely on the age difference but on her immigration history. It was stated that she had earlier married an Overseas Citizen of India (OCI) cardholder on the basis of which she obtained OCI status.

Following the dissolution of that marriage in July 2021, her OCI status was cancelled in November 2023. She subsequently married again in 2022 and sought visa conversion and extension on the basis of that relationship as well. However, she could not obtain the immigration benefits due to deficiencies in the supporting documents, and the marriage ended in November 2025.

The authorities said the present marriage was her third and that their assessment also took into account her prolonged stay in India, previous applications for immigration benefits based on matrimonial relationships, residential arrangements and explanations regarding her source of income and means of sustenance. It thus formed a prima facie opinion that the present marriage could be one of convenience and that the possibility of financial or contractual arrangements to facilitate immigration benefits could not be ruled out.

The court held that the mere fact that the petitioner married an Indian citizen does not, by itself, confer an automatic or indefeasible right to conversion of her existing visa. It further noted that the grant, conversion and extension of visas, as well as the regulation of the stay of foreign nationals in India, fall within the domain of the competent authorities under the Immigration and Foreigners Act, 2025.

It thus said that the respondent authorities are entitled to take into consideration all the relevant factors that may warrant scrutiny.

The court held, "In the present case, a foreign national cannot claim an unconditional right to reside in India or insist upon the grant of a particular category of visa merely on the basis of a matrimonial relationship."

It observed that the court cannot substitute its own assessment for that of the competent authority in a matter concerning admission of a foreign national. The court, therefore, dismissed the plea, however, it clarified that it had not undertaken any adjudication as to the validity or genuineness of the marriage.