The Thiruparankundram hill in Madurai faces a long-standing dispute over religious access and rituals. A 1923 court ruling divided the hill between temple and mosque property, yet tensions remain. Recent conflicts involve lighting a festival lamp near the summit, a practice authorities stopped in the 19th and early 20th centuries.

Background of the case

Thiruparankundram hill rises about 1050 feet on the outskirts of Madurai. At its base stands the Arulmigu Subramanian Swamy Cave Temple, associated with Hindu worship for centuries. Over time, the hill also became home to Jain rock beds and caves carved over many centuries. At the summit lies the burial site of the Sufi saint Sikkandar Badhusha, where a dargah later came up.

These layers gave the hill more than one identity. It has been referred to as “Samanar Hill” for its Jain associations and “Sikkandar Hill” after the Sufi saint. It has also been a site that regularly requires police deployment during festivals, when questions of access and movement tend to surface.

The hill’s legal history dates back to a civil suit filed in 1920, in which the Arulmigu Subramanian Swamy Temple Devasthanam, which administers the temple, claimed title over the entire hill.

In 1923, the trial court ruled that most of the unoccupied hill and the pilgrim path were temple property, while the topmost peak, the area around the mosque, the Nellithope area, and the steps leading to the mosque were Muslim property. This arrangement became the basis for later disputes.

Earlier disputes

Litigation over Thiruparankundram continued over the decades.

In 2021, a dispute arose over replacing a wooden flagstaff at the dargah with an iron one. In early 2025, another controversy followed an attempt to perform animal sacrifice at the hilltop, which a three-judge Bench later prohibited, noting that the hill is a protected monument under rules of the Archaeological Survey of India.

The present dispute centres on the lighting of a festival lamp at a stone pillar near the hilltop. The pillar is said to be a Deepathoon, a ceremonial structure meant for lighting lamps. It is located approximately 50 metres from the dargah.

Records placed before the court showed that attempts to light lamps near the summit were stopped by authorities in the 19th and early 20th centuries, citing the absence of established custom and public order concerns.

The issue returned to court in 1994, when volunteers sought to light a Deepam at the peak. In a 1996 judgment, the High Court directed that the Karthigai Deepam be lit at a different site on the lower slopes, near the Uchipillaiyar Temple. It also allowed the Devasthanam to consider alternative locations, provided the “suitable place [is] at least 15 metres away from the Dargah, the flight of steps and the Nellithope area”.

For decades, therefore, the Deepam was lit at the Deepa Mandapam near the Uchipillaiyar temple.

How the dispute resurfaced

Against this backdrop, a group of worshippers approached the court in late November 2025 seeking permission to light the Karthigai Deepam on December 3 at the “Deepathoon” on the hilltop.

On December 1, a single-judge bench allowed the petitions, viewing the act as a restoration of religious practice and directing the temple management to light the lamp with police assistance.

“Karthigai is also a festival of light. Lamps are lit all over the house and not in the pooja room alone. The Karthigai Deepam shall be lit from this year onwards at Deepathoon also,” the court said. When temple authorities expressed difficulty in implementing the order, citing law-and-order concerns, the judge initiated contempt proceedings and permitted a small team to climb the hill under security cover.

State objections

The state government and the Hindu Religious and Charitable Endowments (HR&CE) Department challenged the order, arguing that disputes over custom and usage must be decided under the HR&CE Act and not through writ proceedings. They also questioned whether the pillar was religious in nature, suggesting it could be a survey marker or a remnant linked to Jain use.

Citing concerns over crowd control and public peace, the police imposed prohibitory orders under Section 163 of the Bharatiya Nagarik Suraksha Sanhita. The lamp was not lit on the festival day last year, leading to appeals by the State, the HR&CE Department, and representatives of the dargah.

What the Division Bench held

A Division Bench of the Madras High Court then ruled on the matter earlier this year.

It held that the structure was a Deepathoon, noting that it had a carved cavity capable of holding oil and wicks, and rejected the claim that it was merely a survey marker.

On law and order, the court said the administration’s apprehensions were “nothing but an imaginary ghost,” adding that allowing a small team of temple officials to go up the hill once a year could not be considered unmanageable.

At the same time, the court modified the single judge’s order, directing that the Devasthanam may light the lamp at the Deepathoon only through a limited team, with no public access. The District Collector was asked to coordinate the exercise, subject to conditions imposed by the Archaeological Survey of India to protect the monument.

How the matter reached the Supreme Court

In June this year, the Tamil Nadu government challenged the Division Bench’s ruling.

The dargah authorities and other parties also approached the apex court.

The Tamil Nadu government contended on Wednesday that allowing the lamp-lighting at the stone pillar near the dargah could lead to thousands of survey pillars across the country acquiring a religious character.

Hearing the matter ahead of this year’s Karthigai Deepam festival, the Supreme Court on November 20 passed an interim order allowing the lamp to be lit at the disputed pillar on November 24, but only as a one-time measure and subject to safeguards.

The top court, however, stayed the Madras High Court judgment allowing the lighting of the lamp at the “Deepathoon”.