Extortion remains a persistent problem in Bengal despite political shifts. Although the BJP now holds power, allegations of corruption against its members continue to surface. The finance minister said, "the continuation of such monetary extraction would adversely affect the process of the restoration of public trust" in the state.
Extortion -- a cottage industry in Bengal? -- is a resilient beast. It appears to be a constant despite the turns in the electoral fortunes of political parties in this state. The Bharatiya Janata Party, when it was in the Opposition, had been critical of the malpractice that prevailed during the reign of the erstwhile Trinamool Congress government. The BJP is in power now; but the party, some fear, may lose its sheen because of the persistent allegations of extortion against its representatives. To their credit, several BJP leaders have spoken out repeatedly against this malaise. The state party chief, ministers in the state cabinet, and even a Union minister of state are among these notable voices of conscience. Recently, Murshidabad witnessed the novel sight of a BJP MLA taking to the streets with a microphone urging residents not to yield to such unjust coercion. But the rot is yet to be stemmed. This may, in the long run, have consequences: the finance minister has said, quite correctly, that the continuation of such monetary extraction would adversely affect the process of the restoration of public trust. The ugly phenomenon also raises questions about the BJP's organisational edifice in the state. Has the party been able to separate the wheat from the chaff -- corrupt, malleable foot soldiers from a rival party? Evidently, it is yet to succeed on this front. This should embarrass a party built on a regimental ethic.
What must be mentioned is that rent-seeking is a multidimensional phenomenon. Corruption and its nexus with politics are but two of its causal manifestations. The third -- the state of Bengal's economy -- is an important facet. The long winter in Bengal's industrial regeneration has created a constituency that seeks to profit by mendacious means. The lure of quick money, intensified by the lack of adequate employment and business opportunities, makes extortion a formidable challenge -- so much so that political colour or ideological affiliation becomes expedient to its practitioners. Hence, the lower tiers of the party continue to 'earn' a livelihood in the old, ignoble way even as entreaties and threats of expulsion rain from the top. Furthermore, this phenomenon is poor advertisement for a state desperate for investment. For the BJP, the battle against clientelism needs to be waged simultaneously on multiple fronts -- economic, political and organisational. Otherwise, the promise of meaningful change will remain on paper for Bengal.
