Indian laws protect the choice to not have a child, but the decision to have one remains left to the private healthcare market. While the Supreme Court recognizes reproductive autonomy, it mostly focuses on existing pregnancies. Citizens now face high costs for fertility treatment without any state financial aid.
Indian laws protect the decision not to have a child through statutes, schemes and subsidies, but the decision to have one is left to the mercy of the private assisted reproduction healthcare market
The reproductive-autonomy jurisprudence as evolved by the Supreme Court under Article 21 of the Constitution is rich yet narrow, focusing primarily on one side of the problem. In Suchita Srivastava v. Chandigarh Administration (2009), the Court held that reproductive choices may be exercised to procreate as well as to abstain from procreating. In X v. Principal Secretary, Health and Family Welfare Department (2022), the Supreme Court extended the right to abortion to unmarried women as an exercise of 'decisional autonomy'.
These, and nearly all other landmark cases are concerned only with an existing pregnancy. The freedom to pursue parenthood through medical treatment, however, has surfaced only at the margins. The Delhi High Court, in 2023, allowed parole of a life convict to attempt IVF, by recognising a "right to parenthood," but only as a claim against a barrier the State itself had erected. No court has yet asked whether the State may leave a citizen's access to infertility care entirely to their own purse. Can a right available to the fertile but structurally withheld from the infertile be called a universal right?
