The Supreme Court on Friday asked applicants to raise their plea before a five-judge bench regarding the appointment of election commissioners. Chief Justice Surya Kant said the request should go to the larger bench when it meets. Advocate Prashant Bhushan argued the application should go before the original two-judge bench.
The applicants have sought a recall of a Supreme Court judgment on a law to appoint the CEC and election commissioners, citing an alleged conflict of interest involving the son of a judge.
The Supreme Court on Friday asked applicants seeking a recall of its September 23 two-judge judgment referring pleas challenging a 2023 law on the appointment of the chief election commissioner and election commissioners to a five-judge Constitution Bench to make their request before the larger bench when it takes up the matter.
A three-judge bench presided over by Chief Justice of India (CJI) Surya Kant said this as it declined to grant the request to list the recall application before the same bench.
Appearing for the applicants, Advocate Prashant Bhushan told the bench, also comprising Justices Joymalya Bagchi and V Mohana, that the application should ideally go before the same bench. "Recall application should go before them. It may be listed next week," he said.
'Raise matter before bench'
The CJI and Justice Bagchi said they can request the five-judge bench when it takes up the matter for hearing.
Bhushan said the matter was referred to a five-judge bench as one of the two judges, Justice S C Sharma, had dissented. "If Justice Sharma had not dissented in this case, then it would not have been referred to the Constitution Bench," he submitted.
CJI Kant said Justice Dipankar Datta, who was the presiding judge, had also agreed to refer it. He added that his role "was only to constitute the bench".
Bhushan reiterated the request to list it before the same bench at the earliest, as Justice Sharma is set to retire on November 29. But the CJI said, "You can raise before the bench when the matter comes. Presiding judge is there in any case."
What the recall application says
On September 23, the two-judge bench of Justices Datta and Sharma had delivered a split verdict on the Centre's request to refer the matter to a Constitution bench. While Justice Datta rejected the prayer, Justice Sharma favoured the reference. Having failed to arrive at a unanimous view, the bench finally agreed to place it before the CJI for reference to a Constitution bench.
The recall application said it is seeking a recall of only Justice Sharma's opinion and recall or suitable modification of the common order "on account of coming to light of a subsequent and material circumstance bearing upon judicial propriety, disclosure and the touchstone of impartial adjudication."
It added that after the judgment was pronounced, news outlets reported that Justice Sharma's son, Siddharth Sharma, is the standing counsel for the ECI before the Madhya Pradesh High Court. They said this information was not disclosed to the parties during the hearings and added that the judge hearing it in such circumstances raised questions of conflict of interest.
