Rahul Gandhi sparked a political row after calling India’s economy a disaster during his talk at Columbia University on Tuesday. The Lok Sabha Opposition leader claimed the country faces massive unemployment and broken business systems. The BJP hit back, calling his remarks anti-India propaganda as the war of words intensified.
Discussing the recent protests seeking electoral reforms in India at Columbia University, the Lok Sabha LoP said the youth of India were unhappy with the government
Lok Sabha Opposition leader Rahul Gandhi has painted a grim picture of the economy in his talk at Columbia University on Tuesday, drawing retorts from the government and the BJP.
Discussing the recent protests seeking electoral reforms in India with The New York Times' Lydia Polgreen, Rahul said: "A lot of the kids (at the protest) are actually children of people who saw the Prime Minister as having big potential and the reason (they seem to have lost hope)... is they do not see a future for themselves....
"So what they're actually saying to their parents, and we're hearing this from the parents that listen, you're not successful. You don't have a job.... You can't tell us to do what you did because it doesn't work. Look, the blunt truth is that India is sitting on an economic disaster."
He added: "The media can brush it aside, but India's got a massive unemployment problem.... I said that the (services-based) economic model stopped giving results almost a decade ago.... The Prime Minister has been putting across one idea after another....
Rahul added: "But what's happened? Absolutely nothing, because the spine of the economy has been broken.... The spine of the economy is small and medium businesses. That's the job creation engine. The spine of the economy, whether we like it or not, is agriculture. That is fundamental in India and required. And the spine of the economy is businesses that compete with each other."
Rahul trained his guns on the two familiar targets.
"Why are the only people who are growing in India called Adani and Ambani?...
"We cannot survive successfully without manufacturing.... You cannot... give enough people jobs through services.... These are fundamental questions that India has to answer -- you're not going to get away from it, right, and we've been getting, we've been trying to get away from it, our Prime Minister has been trying to make us get away from it for the last decade. And now suddenly he's realising, people are realising, that no, you cannot.... And what's allowed him to do it... is what has been done to the Indian electoral system because without that he couldn't do it."
Rahul added: "I think... America or countries like Germany and England are in a much bigger soup than we are. Our costs are much lower. We have much bigger numbers, and we can take a lot more suffering and pain.... I worry that you know another 10 years of this, five years of this, we'll really be in trouble."
On his support for leftists like student leader Neha Bora, Rahul said: "There is no Left and Right in India. Left and Right is a Western concept.... Earlier I would say... the communists are Left and the RSS is right. Now I say... I actually don't accept that structure."
He added: "Our fight is actually not a fight between Left and Right. It's actually a fight between two Indian ideas. We are fighting the BJP. They have a particular vision of our country and it's a vision that has been there in our country for thousands of years, and we who fight the BJP have a different vision, and it's also been there for thousands of years."
Rahul repeated his "vote chori" allegations and said: "Restarting the politics, restarting the democratic structure, removing (chief election commissioner) Gyanesh Kumar -- which we will do -- are the fundamental cornerstones of allowing young people to take power control in India."
On India matching up to the US in GDP, Rahul said this alone doesn't reflect the country's fundamentals, and India should focus on its strengths.
The Congress leader said: "I would rather have a strong United States because it's a good partner for us. For me, there is a need for production in a democratic environment. There are serious problems, as you said, with the Chinese model. I don't particularly like the coercive nature of their model. I don't like the fact that they're not democratic. I value the fact that we used to be democratic and I want to bring that back. And I think... if we build a model that allows for production in a democratic environment, we will move much faster than people imagine."
The BJP hit back. Union minister Pralhad Joshi posted on X: "But before anyone takes his economic sermons seriously, let's look at what independent global institutions and credible data actually say about New India: IMF, Moody's & S&P Global: Upgraded India's growth outlook to around 7%. Goldman Sachs: Projects India's economy to grow at 7.2% in 2027. Employment: Unemployment declined to 4.9% (PLFS, October 2026). Higher Education: Enrolment has surged by 31.5%....
"While Hon'ble PM Shri @narendramodi ji earns global respect and takes India's stature and the pride of the Tiranga to new heights, Rahul Gandhi continues to play the role of India's Chief Exporter of Anti-India Propaganda."
