PPFAS Mutual Fund CIO Rajeev Thakkar said markets overstated the AI threat to Indian IT. He noted, "ChatGPT launched four years ago. Four years is enough time for IT CEOs to get the message." While shares of TCS, Infosys, HCLTech and Wipro fell, he argued that outsourcing remains vital for implementation.
PPFAS Mutual Fund CIO Rajeev Thakkar believes markets have overstated the threat artificial intelligence (AI) poses to India's information technology sector, arguing that the disruption is being confused with the elimination of outsourcing. "ChatGPT launched four years ago," he told investors at the fund house's 13th unitholders' meeting. "Four years is enough time for IT CEOs to get the message." If AI were about to kill outsourcing, the impact should already be visible in companies' earnings, rather than just in analyst notes, he argued. Thakkar was defending PPFAS' IT holdings, which have come under pressure this year.
Shares of TCS, Infosys, HCLTech and Wipro have lost nearly 30% of their value in 2026. Their valuations have fallen to 15-18 times earnings, levels last seen during the 2008-09 financial crisis. Narratives and facts "There are narratives and there are facts," Thakkar said. "We are not entitled to our own facts." He acknowledged that AI will change software development but rejected the argument that this would spell the end of outsourcing. "AI may write much of the code," he said. "The work of implementing it remains." PPFAS' exposure to IT stocks is below 10% of its Flexicap portfolio. Thakkar described the position as a deliberate contrarian bet rather than an oversight.
"People are saying, 'Can't you see the writing on the wall? These companies are becoming obsolete,'" he said, summing up the bearish view before challenging it. Market has priced in disruption early The concerns are not without basis. Jefferies and CLSA have both cut their target prices for Indian IT stocks in recent weeks, citing AI-related risks. However, operating numbers suggest a more measured outlook. Fitch still expects mid-single-digit revenue growth for the sector in 2026, slower than earlier levels but not indicative of a collapse. Large IT companies are already shifting contracts towards outcome-based pricing as clients seek productivity gains.
This suggests AI is changing how work is priced, rather than eliminating the work itself. Thakkar's argument is that the market has priced in greater pain, and at a faster pace, than the earnings data currently supports. A warning beyond IT Thakkar's scepticism towards market narratives extended beyond the IT sector. He contrasted a high-PE quick-commerce company with Coal India, which he said trades at around seven times earnings, offers a 6.6% dividend yield and generates significantly higher profits. "Even if they grow, for a company earning less than Rs 500 crores to reach Rs 33,000 crores in profit will take a while," he said, referring to an unnamed stock riding a popular market theme.
He also cited the 2007 real estate bubble as a cautionary example. "People who bought DLF at the IPO made less than savings-bank returns over 19 years," he said. "Those who bought at the peak still haven't broken even."
