Prime Minister Narendra Modi criticised India Inc on Thursday for low innovation and job creation. Industry leaders took the feedback well but asked for policy reforms to help businesses grow. A senior industrialist called it an "invigorating speech" and said many firms are already working hard to sell quality products globally.
Prime Minister Narendra Modi's sharp criticism of India Inc over inadequate investments in innovation, sluggish job creation and other similar issues, has evoked a mixed but largely constructive response from industry leaders.
While corporate executives acknowledged need for introspection on these matters, some also pointed to structural and policy hurdles that constrain businesses.
"invigorating speech'
A senior industrialist who was at the event on Thursday described PM's talk as an "invigorating speech" that was "taken in the right spirit."
While accepting PM's talk as a clarion call for industries is to push harder and faster on innovation, he stressed that "painting the entire corporate world in a single brush is also not right." Many of our manufacturers are today selling world class products globally and have a strong emphasis on quality, he noted.
Regarding private sector using corporate tax cuts to boost profits, he admitted slow capex in previous years but said it is now picking up. "As for salaries, every company needs to look at their books and see if they are paying their workforce right," the person said.
Anil Kumar Sood, Professor and Co-Founder, Institute for Advanced Studies in Complex Choices (IASCC), said businesses need to focus on capex with increased capital productivity, which has not been the case during the recent years. "Unfortunately, even when labour productivity has been going up, the capital productivity has not gone up," he said.
He counts corporate tax reduction as an "inappropriate policy choice" as companies such as consumer and IT firms have benefitted but not invested back.
"Our trade policy needs to focus on long-term domestic value-addition, which cannot be achieved through QCO-based approach. Both business and the government need to invest in research and innovation with a long-term focus," he said, flagging a high dependence on China in the industrial sector.
A software product entrepreneur, whose company invests more than 10 per cent of revenue on R&D, said that the PM's intent on R&D is commendable, but policymakers need to iron out structural issues hindering innovation.
"We are not asking the government to put more money in R&D. But they can bring back some of the large R&D-linked tax breaks that used to be there earlier. Many other countries have it."
IP regime
The other reform is around IP regime. "In China patents are granted within three to four weeks, but here the process can take more than two years. Imagine an AI patent's worth after two years" the entrepreneur said
Pankaj Bansal, founder of HR consulting firm PeopleStrong, says the PM asked the right questions around jobs and salaries.
"Yes, there are challenges across industries but companies have to introspect about what they are paying their people, especially the entry-level salaries," he said. Companies must make some hard changes around pay of staff in the 0-5 years brackets, he added.
However, he admitted that the impact of AI and the need for improving skill training must be taken into account before placing blame on companies.
Anil Agarwal, Chairman, Vedanta Group also took to X to post his thoughts on the speech.
"We are all very excited and energised by the Prime Minister's inspiring speech to industry at FICCI. He was so open and straight-forward," he said, calling for a privatisation drive, simplified industrial approvals through self-certification, and reforms to mineral and hydrocarbon exploration among other reforms.
Jyotsna Suri, Chairperson and Managing Director of Bharat Hotels Ltd, told media agencies that FICCI would take the PM's requests seriously and prepare a set of practical, achievable policy reform proposals for submission to him.
On the PM pulling up industry for salary hikes, a partner at a HR consulting firm explained that inflation levels are considered in deciding annual salary hikes and the Government has continued to show official reported inflation at sub-5 per cent. Our companies too have kept salary hikes at an average of 8-9 per cent, he said. "Remove the hurdles for more companies to emerge freely, and demand-supply dynamics will raise salaries," he added.
