Binance security breach: What should affected Indian users do to protect their crypto assets?

Market Mastery

Webinar by Vishal Malkan

Find the weak links

in your portfolio by Vishal Malkan

The latest security breach at Binance, the world’s largest cryptocurrency exchange, has renewed attention on how cryptocurrency exchanges handle customer losses from cyberattacks, stolen digital assets, and unauthorised withdrawals.

Binance reported a security breach on October 30 with an estimated impact of around $6.3 billion. "We have worked with blockchain partners to freeze affected assets, with $3 billion frozen on-chain so far," Binance stated in its official release, adding that “Binance will cover all losses from the SAFU fund and the company’s funds. User funds are safe.”

According to Binance's initial investigation, the platform said the security incident may involve a compromised DevOps engineer’s laptop, which allowed an attacker to access a service container and submit unauthorised withdrawal transactions. We have found no evidence of any wallet private key leak.

Crypto markets came under sharp selling pressure after a report of a security breach incident at Binance. Bitcoin fell to a low of near $76,148 in early trading on October 30 from $80,000 levels, and later recovered marginally to trade near $76,900 (20:18 IST), though representing a 5.02 percent decline over the past 24 hours and 5.80 percent in a week.

Binance had previously operated in India without meeting regulatory requirements. It resumed services in August 2024 after registering with the Financial Intelligence Unit-India (FIU-IND) and paying a Rs 18.82 crore penalty. The FIU-IND is India's central agency responsible for receiving, analysing and sharing information on suspicious financial transactions with relevant authorities.

Legal experts say that if the crypto exchange fails to honour its commitment, Indian investors may face legal and practical hurdles. This is because, unlike bank deposits, cryptocurrency investments in India lack statutory deposit insurance or a guaranteed compensation mechanism.

The Reserve Bank of India (RBI) has repeatedly stated that cryptocurrency products and non-fungible tokens (NFTs) are unregulated in India and can be highly risky. There may be no regulatory recourse for any loss from such transactions.

Is crypto exchange liable for refunds?

Aniket Ghosh, Partner, King Stubb & Kasiva, Advocates and Attorneys, said, "Indian law has no crypto-specific provision that compels a refund. No deposit insurance or statutory compensation fund covers virtual digital assets. The obligation therefore rests mainly on contract and on Binance’s own commitments."

He added that the exchange’s public assurance carries weight, but its enforceability depends on the platform's user terms, including governing law, arbitration clauses and liability caps. Until the exchange publishes a formal compensation framework, customers should treat the pledge as strong assurance rather than a guaranteed legal right.

The latest survey by LocalCircles involving nearly 11,000 citizens finds that 82 percent of respondents in India expressed little or no trust in cryptocurrencies. The findings showed that 66 percent had zero trust in cryptocurrencies, while 16 percent reported low confidence. Only 4 percent expressed a high level of trust and 6 percent reported average confidence. Another 8 percent remained undecided.

Crypto as property: What does it mean?

Shruti Lohia, Partner at AQUILAW, said the legal position could also be influenced by the growing recognition of cryptocurrency as property under common-law jurisprudence.

"If crypto is treated as property, an exchange holding it for its users is acting in a custodial capacity, and a custodian is expected to safeguard the assets entrusted to it," she said.

According to Lohia, customers may pursue contractual, negligence, consumer protection, and fiduciary-duty claims if losses are passed on through balance reductions, haircuts, or other loss-sharing arrangements.

What should affected users do?

For affected Indian customers, the immediate priority should be preserving evidence and reporting suspicious transactions. Ghosh advised customers to retain account statements, transaction histories, KYC records, and communications, and to lodge written complaints through the exchange's official support channels.

"If they see unauthorised transactions on their own accounts or wallets, they should report them on cybercrime.gov.in or helpline 1930," he said.

Can investors approach consumer courts?

Customers may also explore remedies under the Consumer Protection Act, 2019, which allows complaints involving deficiency in service or unfair trade practices. A breach of contractual obligations could provide another avenue for seeking compensation.

However, pursuing these remedies may not guarantee a quick refund. Ghosh noted that enforcing an Indian order against an offshore platform could create jurisdictional and practical difficulties.

Will customers recover their money?

Lohia said the biggest challenge for Indian investors would be enforcement, given that Binance is not incorporated in India. Ultimately, recovery will depend on the exchange honouring its commitment and the success of ongoing asset-recovery efforts.