Johnny Depp’s Ebenezer hits cinemas this weekend, prompting a fresh look at Charles Dickens’ classic A Christmas Carol. Dickens started writing the book in the autumn of 1843 after his works got pirated. The story shows how Scrooge changed in a single night, targeting the human heart over social institutions.

With Johnny Depp's 'Ebenezer' in cinemas this weekend, a first proper read of A Christmas Carol finds a book Dickens wrote in about six weeks, after years of watching his novels get pirated. Scrooge changes in a single night, which critics have been questioning for a long time.

A Gen Z Reviews the Classics' is a new weekly column on Firstpost. We revisit great books and films, and talk about why they remain relevant even today.

Ebenezer Scrooge is the grumpiest old man on the planet. A Christmas Carol is a folk tale that has taken on a multitude of forms in pop culture -- and therefore everyone is familiar with some or the other variation of it by now, but it has an enthralling magical fairytale like feeling about it.

Dickens is a bit tough to begin with. I read Oliver Twist when I was about ten but for some reason, for all its hype couldn't get through A Christmas Carol no matter how hard I tried. With Johnny Depp's Ebenezer releasing, I thought it was only the right time to try again, and the first few pages made me feel like a little kid, eagerly waiting for the joy of Christmas Day.

Bah humbug, with receipts

The book turns out to have a grudge involved. William Wrigg, in an old essay for The English Journal, notes that Dickens started writing in the autumn of 1843, after years of having his books pirated and a trip to America, argued for international copyright, and got nowehere. Boston and New York cheered him on and kept selling his novels without paying him a penny. He finished the Carol in about six weeks.

The irritation is palpable on page. Bob Cratchit gets a freezing office and a Christmas Day off that Scrooge resents handing over. The men collecting for the poor are asked a question -- are there no prisons, no workhouses? Scrooge thinks the matter is settled. The state has built places for people like the Cratchits, so he owes them nothing further, and Tiny Tim (Cratchit's son) is what that logic looks like in a house with no money.

Wrigg points out something odd about Dickens. He attacked almost every part of English society and never once asked for an institution to be pulled down. His target was the human heart. It is a sound reading, though it leaves a gap. A kinder Scrooge helps the Cratchits, thereby giving the novel its happy ending.

Reformed by dawn

If the heart is the target, it has to change, and Scrooge's changes in a night. The critic Edmund Wilson reckoned he would be back to his old suspicious self once the party ended. Humphry House, another critic, noted that there is never a sign of Scrooge struggling to keep up his new character.

The scholar Elliot Gilbert, in his essay "The Ceremony of Innocence", calls this the Scrooge problem, and he is fair about why it bothers people -- men who spend decades bullying clerks and turning away the poor do not wake up generous. But perhaps it is a Christmas miracle.

Gilbert's answer is that the complaint misreads what Dickens is doing. He argues the book's target is Scrooge's rationalism, the Victorian faith in accumulation, and that the reader's doubt about the change is that same rationalism talking. For Gilbert the story is about a man finding his own innocence again. The Ghost of Christmas Past shows a boy alone in an empty schoolroom with Ali Baba and Robinson Crusoe for company, until his sister Fan arrives to take him home for good and all. A slightly older Scrooge loses his fiancée because he is now besotted with money.

Curated by ghosts

The spirits barely argue with Scrooge. They take him to look at things -- his lonely schooldays, Fezziwig's Christmas party, the Cratchits crowded round a small dinner. An essay on sympathy in the story says this is the whole method. Scrooge watches scenes from his own life and other people's, and the watching is what softens him.

The narrator does it to us as well, claiming to stand at your elbow while Scrooge looks on, so the reader ends up watching alongside him.

The essay also finds a hole. Dickens never explains how looking at something makes a person care about it. He asks us to take that on trust, the same way he asks us to take the overnight change on trust. Anyone who has scrolled past a news story about someone else's terrible week and felt very little will know the problem.

In Scrooged, the 1988 comedy in which Bill Murray plays a television executive putting on his own version of the Carol. At the end he steps out of the broadcast and tells viewers to switch off and go and live in the real world.