Kaynes Technology shares fell 20% on Monday, November 16, after the company missed Q2 earnings expectations. Revenue growth hit a multi-quarter low of 4%, while net profit dropped 66%. The firm also started restating past financials due to auditor concerns, as management works to fix errors in their reported accounts.
Shares of Kaynes Technology India Ltd. fell 20% in reaction to their September quarter results on Monday, November 16, which missed expectations across parameters.
Kaynes Tech reported revenue growth of 4%, which is a multi-quarter low. The revenue figure of ₹952 crore was also below what the CNBC-TV18 poll had projected.
EBITDA margin fell 320 basis points to 13.2%, also below the poll expectation of 14.7%. Net profit fell 66% from last year, led by a sharp drop in other income. Gross margins were also down 140 basis points from last year.
For the first half of the current financial year, Kaynes Tech's revenue growth stood at 18%, while margins were down 200 basis points from last year to 14.1%.
Brokerage firm Equirus has highlighted multiple factors from the auditor observations and financial restatements as well. Here are some of the key highlights from that:
Auditor’s limited review report on Q2FY27 consolidated financial results carries a qualified conclusion, primarily on account of the co’s investment in its associate, Mixx Technologies Inc.
Kaynes has recognised its share of losses of ₹6 crore in the second quarter and ₹10.4 crore in the first half of FY27 based on the available information. This creates an element of uncertainty around the reported financial impact of the associate.
Some of the key corrections include premature revenue recognition in cases where control of goods had not been transferred to customers, excess overheads being capitalised into inventory, and inadequate provisions for slow-moving/non-moving inventory and doubtful trade receivables.
The restatements also involve several balance sheet reclassifications. For instance, bill discounting and supplier finance arrangements have been reclassified as borrowings where they carried the nature of financing obligations.
We believe these developments raise concerns around the quality and reliability of Kaynes’ historical financial reporting, particularly given the nature and number of corrections identified. However, the company has undertaken the restatement exercise to rectify the errors, apparently, Equirus wrote in its note.
Here's what the management of Kaynes Tech said in its earnings call:
Smart meter is high margin biz impacting overall margins
Smart meter will come back with more disciplined portfolio
Smart meter rev decline 12% in Q1 & declined by 80% in Q2
FY27 confident of growing electronic biz at 30% 2x market growth
Rev trend shows deliberate action to reduce smart meter
Inventory levels continue to remain elevated
Receivable have come down in smart meter seg
PCB & OSAT contribution started in Q3 giving us confidence of stronger H2
Bill discounting for receivables shown as a part of borrowing
Kaynes Tech Shares Are A Buy Or Sell?
JPMorgan has maintained its "neutral" rating on Kaynes with a price target of ₹3,150, stating that the earnings miss was driven by lower smart meters contribution given management focus on reducing the net working capital.
The strong revenue growth seen in the automotive and railways business was offset by industrial, medical and IoT business.
Three key things to watch in the earnings call would be reasons behind the restatement of financials, rationale for the 49% stake sale in Kaynes Semicon, and update on finding a solution for the smart meter business, JPMorgan noted.
CLSA also has a "hold" rating on Kaynes with a price target of ₹3,580, highlighting the EBITDA miss, which indicates a ramp down of the smart metering division.
24 analysts have coverage on Kaynes Tech, of which seven have a "buy" rating, eight have a "hold" rating and nine have a "sell" rating on the stock. The consensus estimate of price targets implies an upside potential of 8% from current levels.
Shares of Kaynes Tech are down 20% in trade on Monday at ₹2,838.8. The stock is down 20% so far this year.
