Gold prices rose, but many investors failed to capture the full rally. Between March 2024 and October 2026, Gold ETFs got Rs 1.01 lakh crore in inflows. While gold is a popular choice for security, data showed that other investment strategies could have earned much higher returns for Indian households.
Gold is one of the few assets Indians buy without first asking what it will return. We buy it for weddings, festivals and family security. For generations, it has symbolised wealth preservation and financial protection. So, when gold prices rise sharply, it creates a perception that everyone holding gold has become wealthier. But there is a difference between an asset performing well and investors actually capturing those returns. Also read: Gold's 25% fall in 2026 among sharpest since 1980: What history says about recoveries After an extraordinary rally followed by a sharp correction, three questions matter: When did investors buy gold?
What drove returns in India? And what opportunities did they give up by choosing gold over other investments? Gold went up. Did investors capture the rally? Between March 2024 and October 2026, Gold ETFs attracted cumulative net inflows of Rs 1.01 lakh crore. Interestingly, nearly 50 percent came during 2026, after gold had already appreciated substantially. To understand the impact, we compared actual investor cash flows with two hypothetical approaches involving the same cumulative investment of Rs 1,01,397 crore. The annualised return on actual investor flows was just 15.50 percent. Investing a fixed amount every month would have delivered 29.70 percent, while investing the entire amount at the beginning would have generated 32.72 percent.
Domestic returns, therefore, depend on global prices, currency movements and import duties. Our analysis of the past 20 years shows that gold delivered average annual returns of 11.92 percent in dollar terms, compared with 16.05 percent in rupees. The 4.13 percentage-point difference is largely attributable to rupee depreciation. A recent one-year period illustrates this particularly well. International gold prices declined 5.40 percent, yet Indian prices rose 10.23 percent. This divergence of 15.63 percentage points was largely driven by 7 percent rupee depreciation and an increase in customs duty from 6 percent to 15 percent.
But can this additional return continue indefinitely? Not necessarily. A stronger rupee or lower import duties could put pressure on domestic gold prices even if international prices remain unchanged. What else could that money have earned? The more interesting question is not just how much wealth gold created, but whether the same money could have earned more elsewhere. Our analysis estimates that Indian households invested Rs 118.97 lakh crore in gold between 2013 and 2026. At November 2026 valuations, this would have grown to Rs 464.99 lakh crore. However, investing the equivalent amount in the equity mutual fund basket used in our comparison would have generated Rs 554.42 lakh crore, nearly Rs 90 lakh crore more.
This does not mean households literally lost Rs 90 lakh crore. It is a hypothetical comparison. Gold bought for weddings, jewellery and family requirements serves purposes that equities cannot replace. Nevertheless, it highlights an important distinction: earning positive returns is not necessarily the same as maximising wealth creation. Every investment choice carries an opportunity cost. The recent correction: What has changed? After an extraordinary rally, international gold prices have fallen nearly 31 percent from their January 2026 peak of $5,405 per ounce, while domestic prices have corrected 25 percent from Rs 1,75,231 per 10 grams.
Concerns over US inflation and tighter monetary policy have increased the attractiveness of interest-bearing investments. The US 10-year Treasury yield has crossed 5 percent, while a stronger dollar has added pressure on gold. Investor behaviour has also contributed. Momentum-driven buying and leveraged positions during the rally gave way to profit booking and the unwinding of futures positions as prices declined. Demand is moderating, too. Global jewellery consumption fell 17 percent year-on-year in Q3 2026, while Indian consumption declined 20 percent. Global Gold ETF inflows slowed from $10 billion in September to $2.7 billion in October.
The correction does not mean gold has lost its long-term relevance. But it reinforces a familiar lesson: past performance cannot be extrapolated indefinitely, and a sharp price decline does not automatically make an investment attractive. Should gold be part of every investor's portfolio? As a broad allocation framework, investors can consider allocating up to 50 percent of their debt allocation to gold, or 10-15 percent of their overall portfolio. Those already overweight on gold should consider rebalancing towards their strategic allocation rather than adding exposure simply because prices have corrected.
The objective of investing is not to own whichever asset has delivered the highest recent returns. It is to build a portfolio that offers the highest probability of achieving financial goals. Ultimately, the real measure of wealth creation is not how brightly an asset shines, but how effectively it contributes to an investor's overall financial journey. The author is the Joint CEO Anand Rathi Wealth Limited. Disclaimer: The views and investment tips expressed by experts on Moneycontrol.com are their own and not those of the website or its management. Moneycontrol.com advises users to check with certified experts before taking any investment decisions.
